Exploring Alternative Funding Pathways for Startups

Securing capital for a startup extends far beyond traditional venture capital, encompassing options like crowdfunding, debt financing, and revenue-share agreements. However, when aiming for a billion-dollar valuation, is all funding truly equivalent? Dr. Astrid Scholz, co-founder of Zebras Unite; Sydney Thomas, a principal at Precursor Ventures; and Brian Brackeen, founding partner of Lightship Capital, engaged in a discussion at TC Sessions: Justice, examining alternative funding routes and questioning whether the democratization of capital is genuine.

The Decision to Diverge from Traditional Venture Capital

Currently, Scholz is developing Zebras Unite, a founder-led cooperative dedicated to fostering more sustainable, ethical, and inclusive startups. She explained that while the organization’s capital arm could have adopted a conventional fund structure, they ultimately opted for innovative alternatives, exemplified by the Future Economy Lab.

This lab, concentrating on assisting founders in identifying financing instruments suited to their specific industries, was hosted in Montreal with a particular emphasis on climate technology.

• SEC loosens crowdfunding regs so small businesses can raise alternative financing in pandemic
• AngelList pioneers rolling VC funds in pivot to SaaS
• Who are the major revenue-based investing VCs?
• How to approach (and work with) the 3 types of corporate VCs

Building Inclusive Strategies Within Venture Capital

Venture capital isn’t inherently problematic, and the current market demonstrates a substantial demand for backing promising concepts. The core issue arises when analyzing which ideas receive funding versus those that don’t, with underrepresented founders facing disproportionately higher rejection rates compared to their white counterparts.

Establishing clear standards benefits all parties involved, and in the venture capital landscape, transparency regarding investor practices can mitigate signaling risk and establish realistic expectations for early-stage founders.

Lightship Capital utilizes traditional venture capital, but Brackeen believes they apply it in a manner that is more inclusive of founders.

• Flexible VC: A new model for startups targeting profitability
• Venture capital gets less diverse in 2020
• If you’re not investing in diverse founders, you’re a bad investor

The Impact of Initial Funding on Future Opportunities

Thomas highlighted the recent closure of Indie.vc, an alternative financing program geared towards slow-growth, bootstrapped founders, as a potential lesson for those seeking funding from the numerous available programs.

She further elaborated that this isn’t an isolated incident, referencing a post by Precursor founding partner Charles Hudson detailing the complexities of early-stage cap tables.

• A recapitalization reckoning
• Founders seeking their first check need a fundraising sales funnel

Brackeen added that his firm favors non-dilutive financing both before and after initial investment. While pitch competitions can aid a startup’s launch, they are less effective in facilitating progress between funding stages. This discussion addresses the initial question: is all capital truly equal in the eyes of investors? A cap table showcasing diverse financing structures and notes, as Thomas pointed out, could lead a subsequent investor to decline based on perception rather than a lack of belief in the vision.

Recapitalizations, where startups restructure their cap tables to remove older investors, onboard new ones, and adjust equity and debt management, are a potential consequence.

Scholz emphasized the importance of considering capital limitations alongside other corporate structures that could influence a startup’s trajectory.

• Should your startup take the public benefit or B corp route?
• Which types of startups are most often profitable?

The Future Relevance of Venture Capital

The conversation broadened to explore the potential relevance of venture capital in the next five years. While Scholz questioned its current importance, Brackeen and Thomas, as venture capitalists, engaged in a good-natured discussion about the future of their chosen asset class.

• Venture capital is going to get even bigger, faster and more expensive this year
• Lame LPs, founder referenceability and the future of VC signaling

The full transcript of the discussion is available here.

Early Stage is a leading event designed to provide “how-to” guidance for startup entrepreneurs and investors. Attendees gain firsthand insights from successful founders and VCs regarding business building, fundraising, and portfolio management. Sessions cover all facets of company development – fundraising, recruitment, sales, product-market fit, PR, marketing, and brand building. Each session incorporates audience participation, allowing for questions and discussion.