PlayStation 4 Review - HTG

PlayStation 4 vs. Xbox One: A Comparative Overview

Currently, a significant debate is unfolding across the internet regarding the merits of the PlayStation 4 and the Xbox One, with many consumers seeking guidance on which console represents the superior choice.

Initial Impressions and Core Functionality

A preliminary assessment might suggest a straightforward decision. For individuals prioritizing a dedicated gaming experience, the PlayStation 4 appears to be the more suitable option.

Conversely, those seeking a comprehensive media hub, with expanded functionality beyond gaming, may find the Xbox One to be a more compelling selection.

Beyond the Surface: A More Nuanced Perspective

However, a deeper examination reveals that the distinction isn't entirely clear-cut.

The reality is more complex than a simple categorization based on primary function.

Both consoles offer a range of capabilities that extend beyond their initial positioning, necessitating a more detailed comparison.

Factors such as game availability, online services, and long-term value contribute to the overall assessment.

Ultimately, the optimal choice depends on individual preferences and priorities.

A Personal History of Gaming Consoles

My initial experience with video games began with a Pong console. While the specific brand and model escape my memory, it was a simple, flat, square device featuring two control knobs, a power switch, and a reset button – dedicated solely to playing Pong. Despite its simplicity, it provided considerable entertainment.

Following this, the Atari 2600 stood as the dominant console of its era, launching in 1977 with a retail price of $199. Adjusted for inflation, this equates to over $750 in today’s currency.

The early 1980s saw competition emerge from Mattel’s Intellivision, Coleco Industries’ ColecoVision, and the Magnavox Odyssey². I personally owned a Commodore 64, which was notable for its impressive graphics and sound capabilities.

However, game loading times presented a challenge, often requiring two to five minutes, even with a floppy drive – a particularly memorable experience with Flight Simulator II.

The mid to late 1980s witnessed the rise of the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES). This console played a pivotal role in revitalizing the video game industry and laid the groundwork for the console rivalries we see today.

Many consider the era of 16-bit consoles – Sega’s Genesis and the Super Nintendo – to be a golden age. These systems effectively diminished the appeal of arcades and solidified the position of home consoles in the gaming landscape.

Over time, Sega exited the console market, and Atari disappeared. Nintendo, while still a significant player, has occasionally struggled to maintain its momentum, failing to replicate the success of the Wii with the Wii U.

This evolution has left Microsoft and Sony as the primary contenders. Sony’s first three PlayStation consoles achieved considerable success, while the Xbox, capitalizing on Nintendo’s challenges, established Microsoft’s presence in the gaming world.

The Xbox 360 further cemented Microsoft’s reputation for gaming excellence.

A Comparative Look at the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One

The dynamic between Microsoft and Sony in the gaming console market often resembles a complementary duality. This brings us to the central question: which console emerges as the superior choice – the PlayStation 4 or the Xbox One?

Xbox One: A Multifaceted Entertainment Hub

The Xbox One presents a compelling package with numerous advantages. Fundamentally, it delivers a high-quality gaming experience. Beyond gaming, the console serves as a central hub for entertainment.

It can integrate with your existing cable or satellite television service, and provides access to streaming platforms like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video. Furthermore, voice control functionality enhances the user experience.

While the Xbox One carries a price point $100 higher than the PS4, this includes the Kinect sensor, unlocking a wealth of interactive possibilities.

PlayStation 4: A Gamer-Focused Experience

The PlayStation 4 also offers a remarkable experience, prioritizing gaming above all else. Although capable of streaming services like Netflix, these features are secondary to its core gaming functionality.

Sony has meticulously crafted a console designed to cater to the needs of dedicated gamers. It provides all the necessary tools for players to share their achievements and enhance their gaming identity.

The PS4 is engineered to be the definitive gaming machine, empowering users to showcase their skills and connect with the gaming community.

Ultimately, both consoles deliver exceptional gaming experiences, with the best choice depending on individual preferences and priorities.

A Comparative Look at Gaming Consoles

When assessing the technical specifications of gaming consoles, the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One present remarkably similar profiles, representing a logical advancement over their predecessors, the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360.

Console Specifications: A Detailed Overview

The following table provides a detailed comparison of key features across several gaming platforms.

• PS4
• Xbox One
• Wii U
• PS3 (2012)
• Xbox 360 (2013)

Launch price	$399	$499	$299	$269.99	$299
CPU	1.6 GHz (estimated), AMD eight-core X86 “Jaguar”	1.75 GHz, AMD eight-core X86 “Jaguar”	1.24 GHz, IBM PowerPC-based, tri-core “Espresso”	3.2 GHz, IBM Power Architecture-based, 7-core “Cell Broadband Engine”	3.2 GHz, IBM PowerPC tri-core CPU "Xenon"
GPU	800 MHz, AMD Radeon (“Liverpool”), 8 GB DDR5 @5500 MHz (effective)	853 MHz, AMD Radeon (“Durango”), 8 GB DDR3 @2132 MHz (effective)	550 MHz, AMD Radeon (“Latte”), 2 GB DDR3 @1600 MHz (effective)	550 MHz, Nvidia G70-RSX ("Reality Synthesizer"), 256 MB GDDR @1400 MHz (effective)	500 MHz, ATI Radeon (“Xenos), 512 MB GDDR3 @1400 MHz (effective)
Memory	8 GB DDR5 @5500 MHz	8 GB of DDR3 @2133 MHz	2 GB DDR3 @1600 MHz	256 MB XDR @3.2 MHz	512 MB of GDDR3 @700 MHz
Video	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical	HDMI, Component, Composite, S-Video	HDMI, Analog-AV out, Digital optical	HDMI, VGA, Component, SCART, S-Video, Composite
Supported resolutions	1080p, 1080i, 720p, 480p, 480i	1080p, 720p	1080p, 1080i, 720p, 480p, 480i	1080p, 1080i, 720p, 480p, 480i	1080p, 1080i, 720p, 480p
Connectivity	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical, Bluetooth, USB (2)	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical, USB (3)	HDMI, Component, Composite, S-Video, USB (4)	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical, USB (2)	Proprietary, HDMI, Digital optical, USB (5)
Optical media	DVD/Blu-ray	DVD/Blu-ray	Nintendo proprietary	DVD, Blu-ray, CD	DVD, Blu-ray, CD
Internal storage	500 GB (upgradeable) + USB external storage	500 GB + USB external storage	32 GB (upgradeable) + USB external storage, SD, SDHC	12 GB, 250 GB, 500 GB (upgradeable)	250 GB, 4 GB (upgradeable) + USB external storage, memory card
Communications	Ethernet, 802.11n (2.4 GHz), 802.11g, 802.11b	Ethernet, 802.11n (2.4 GHz, 5 GHz), 802.11g, 802.11b	802.11n (2.4 GHz), 802.11g, 802.11b	Ethernet, 802.11g, 802.11b	Ethernet, proprietary wireless
Backwards compatible	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes but only with about 50% of Xbox titles.

Similarities in Core Components

The PS4 and Xbox One share several key characteristics. Both consoles feature 500 GB of internal storage, high-definition video output capabilities, Wi-Fi connectivity, and support for DVD/Blu-ray optical media.

Both systems utilize comparable 8-core AMD “Jaguar” CPUs, although the Xbox One’s processor operates at a slightly higher clock speed. Both manufacturers prioritized CPUs designed for multitasking and broader functionality beyond gaming, opting for numerous, energy-efficient cores rather than fewer, more powerful ones.

Differences in Graphics and Memory

The primary distinctions lie in the graphics processing units (GPUs) and random access memory (RAM). While both GPUs are based on AMD Radeon architecture, the Xbox One’s GPU boasts a higher clock speed (853 MHz) compared to the PS4’s (800 MHz). However, the PS4 dedicates more processing power to graphics rendering (18 computing units versus 12).

In essence, both GPUs will achieve the same graphical results, but the Xbox One may render them marginally slower. This difference is often imperceptible to the average user and is best observed through detailed benchmark analysis.

RAM Considerations and Future-Proofing

Regarding RAM, both consoles are equipped with 8 GB of system memory. The Xbox One utilizes older DDR3 RAM clocked at 2133 MHz, while the PS4 employs faster DDR5 RAM clocked at 5500 MHz. Similarly, the Xbox One’s GPU uses DDR3, and the PS4’s utilizes DDR5. This suggests Sony invested more in future-proofing its system.

Microsoft incorporates an additional 32 MB of high-speed ESRAM, arranged in four 8 MB blocks, directly integrated onto the processor die. While seemingly small, this ESRAM is exceptionally fast and allows for caching of CPU instructions, reducing latency and increasing bandwidth.

The Impact of ESRAM on Development

The inclusion of ESRAM does mitigate some of the RAM differences, but it also introduces complexity for game developers. Optimizing code to effectively utilize this architecture requires specific expertise, whereas developers for the PS4 can leverage the full capacity of its faster DDR5 RAM without specialized adjustments.

Developers familiar with the Xbox 360’s similar setup may not find this challenging. However, those porting titles from the PS4 might choose to reduce texture quality or resolution rather than dedicate resources to optimizing for the Xbox One’s unique architecture.

Concluding Remarks

Ultimately, the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One offer largely comparable gaming experiences. The differences in specifications are subtle and often have minimal impact on overall performance.

The PlayStation 4 Console

The PlayStation 4 distinguishes itself from the traditionally bulky designs often seen in console manufacturing. Its aesthetic is notably more refined, although it doesn’t necessarily present a strikingly beautiful appearance.

The console’s physical dimensions are approximately 12 inches in width, almost 11 inches in depth, and just over 2 inches in height, making it a practical, if somewhat unremarkable, black box. It’s smaller than a classic VCR, yet considerably larger than the compact Wii.

The PS4’s exterior finish incorporates a combination of matte and glossy textures, with a 2/3 to 1/3 ratio respectively. A preference for matte finishes would be welcome, as glossy surfaces readily display fingerprints and are prone to scratches.

Even with diligent cleaning using a microfiber cloth, minor scratches will inevitably appear over time. Our evaluation unit, less than two weeks old, already exhibits some superficial blemishes on its glossy surface.

A side view reveals the console’s considerable depth and its trapezoidal shape. This seemingly unusual form factor is, in fact, a clever design choice.

The rear of the PS4 is largely dedicated to ventilation, serving as the console’s “lungs.” The device’s shape also provides increased airflow, which is beneficial when placed within a confined entertainment center.

The front panel of the PS4 showcases a minimalist design: two USB 3.0 ports, a slot-loading optical drive, a power button, and an eject button are neatly arranged.

At the rear, Sony has maintained simplicity with a digital optical port, HDMI connection, a Cat5 Ethernet port, and an auxiliary port for accessories like the PlayStation Camera, available separately for around $60.

An internal power supply is housed in the lower left portion of the console, eliminating the need for a separate, bulky power brick.

Overall, the PS4’s design prioritizes simplicity and unobtrusiveness. It’s intended to blend seamlessly into a home entertainment setup, only requiring interaction for USB connections or disc insertion/ejection.

The Dual Shock 4 Controller

While the PS4 console provides the foundation, the included Dual Shock 4 controller truly takes center stage as the primary interface.

The Dual Shock 4 can be described as aesthetically pleasing. It is remarkably well-engineered and provides a comfortable user experience. These observations are not exaggerations.

PC gamers are accustomed to a wide variety of keyboard and mouse configurations, including specialized gaming peripherals. However, these often require a dedicated desk setup.

Console controllers, conversely, must appeal to a broad audience. While dedicated PC gamers can upgrade their peripherals, the console controller is crucial to the overall system experience. The Dual Shock 4 undoubtedly delivers in this regard.

The controller feels particularly comfortable in larger hands, offering a secure grip. Three fingers comfortably wrap around the sculpted grips, eliminating any awkward pinky extension.

The thumbs naturally rest within the rubberized divots on the control sticks. The controller’s weight is also ideal – substantial enough to feel solid, yet light enough to prevent fatigue during extended use.

A minor criticism is that the “share” and “options” buttons may be slightly difficult to press, but this is a minor issue that resolves with familiarization.

The controller’s front features left and right triggers, while the bottom triggers are subtly recessed to provide a secure grip during intense gameplay. A color-changing indicator light between the triggers displays system status and controller identity.

A micro USB connector is located below the light, enabling charging even while the PS4 is in standby mode. An amber glow indicates charging status, mirroring the console’s standby light. Alternatively, standard USB chargers, such as those for Android devices, can be used.

Battery life is reported to be around 10-12 hours. While potentially limiting for marathon gaming sessions, this should be sufficient for typical use, provided the controller is charged regularly. A longer USB cable could also be a useful addition.

The rear of the controller includes a standard headphone jack and support for the PS4 headset, allowing for private audio and voice communication, bypassing the TV’s speakers – a useful feature for late-night gaming.

Finally, the top of the controller houses a small speaker for enhanced audio feedback and a touchpad that also functions as a button. The touchpad’s current utility is limited, but it has the potential to become more valuable as developers explore its capabilities. Swiping through menus, similar to a tablet or smartphone, would be a welcome addition.

An additional controller is available for approximately $60, a reasonable price considering its quality and features. However, including an extra USB cable with the purchase would be a beneficial addition.

Ultimately, the controller is the primary means of interacting with the PS4, and it is a truly enjoyable experience. The Dual Shock 4 may well be considered one of the greatest controllers ever designed.

The PlayStation 4 Experience

Utilizing the PS4 system is genuinely enjoyable. Powering on can be achieved by pressing the small power button located on the console itself, or alternatively, by using the PlayStation button on the controller. Holding the same button will initiate a shutdown or place the console into standby mode.

A cold boot, starting from a powered-off state, requires approximately 22 seconds to reach the login screen, while resuming from standby mode takes around 28 seconds.

Completely powering down the device conserves energy, whereas standby mode consumes roughly 10 watts. However, during downloads, power usage increases to about 60W, with an additional 4W consumed while charging the controller.

Generally, while the system is active but idle, it draws around 90W, which is comparable to a standard desktop PC, typically ranging from 200W to 400W depending on its configuration and workload. Power consumption rises significantly during gameplay. Remember to factor in the electricity usage of your television as well.

Despite its high performance, the PS4 is relatively energy-efficient, with peak loads reaching 130-150 watts. Prolonged operation isn’t recommended, but the convenience of standby mode allows for instant resumption of your game when you return.

Understanding the PS4’s User Interface

The PlayStation 4’s operating system interface is predominantly blue in color. It’s also designed to be simple and clean, creating a visually soothing experience on a large HD television screen.

The background music is pleasant and ambient, resembling new age or space-themed compositions, and is unlikely to become irritating. However, it evokes memories of the Wii’s menu music, and particularly the Wii U’s, though a preference for the former exists due to its distinctly Nintendo-esque quality. Regardless, the system music won’t be disruptive if you become distracted and leave the PS4 on, and it can be disabled within the “Sound and Screen” settings, or simply muted through the television.

Upon logging in, users are presented with three rows of features. The central row, often referred to as the “home row”, provides access to installed games and applications, the web browser, and other essential functions. As new games are installed, the home row expands, prioritizing recently used items towards the front.

Unfortunately, there’s no option to customize this arrangement or pin favorites, potentially resulting in a lengthy row of games and features with older or infrequently used items relegated to the end.

The system utilizes a grid-based layout for navigation. The left control stick or directional buttons are used to move between options and information regarding specific titles. Pressing the control stick down reveals additional details.

Accessing system features and settings, such as the PlayStation Store, notifications, messaging, and profile customization, is done through the top options row.

Is the interface complex? Not at all. It’s designed for ease of use by a broad audience, and a user manual is readily available from the “Settings” menu for those who require assistance.

Sharing Gameplay Experiences

A prominent feature of the PS4 is its robust social sharing capabilities. Several aspects contribute to this functionality. Users can connect their Facebook and Twitter accounts to upload screenshots and gameplay videos directly to their profiles.

Alternatively, gameplay can be streamed live on popular platforms like Twitch and USTREAM.

Furthermore, viewers can watch live streams and videos through the “Live from PlayStation” channel, accessible from the main menu’s home row.

Sony clearly aims to engage gamers and providing numerous options to share gaming experiences is likely to appeal to those who enjoy showcasing their skills or simply connecting with others.

Personalizing Your Profile

During the initial PS4 setup, creating a profile is required. This profile can be accessed and customized by navigating to the options row and selecting “Profile”.

Here, users can edit their profile information, view earned trophies, adjust privacy settings, and manage captured screenshots and videos.

System Settings and Control

Also accessible from the options row, the “Settings” menu serves as a central hub for complete control over your PS4. It contains a comprehensive range of options – too extensive to cover in detail within this review – and users are encouraged to explore its features.

Notable settings include parental controls, system update checks, device configuration, and the ability to initialize the system or wipe profiles clean.

The sheer volume of options may seem daunting, but many will only be relevant to specific users.

Exploring the PlayStation Store

The PlayStation Store enables users to purchase and download new titles without leaving their couch. It’s important to note that many newer Blu-ray titles exceed 25 GB in size – “Killzone: Shadow Fall” is nearly 40 GB, for example.

This has two implications. First, downloads may take a considerable amount of time on standard cable internet connections, and could be problematic for those with data caps. Fortunately, downloads can be scheduled to occur while the system is in standby mode, allowing users to initiate them before going to bed.

Second, the internal storage capacity is only 500 GB. While adequate, the increasing size of games means that storage space will quickly become limited as more games, captures, and application save data are accumulated.

Fortunately, Sony has made the PS4 remarkably easy to upgrade. A 1-terabyte 2.5” hard drive can be purchased online for approximately $80. Adding another $20 for an external enclosure for your existing hard drive allows for a nearly threefold increase in storage capacity for around $100 and an hour of your time.

Alternatively, a solid state drive (SSD) could be installed to significantly improve performance, but SSDs with sufficient capacity (500 GB and higher) remain relatively expensive. Regardless, upgrade options are available without voiding the warranty.

Streaming Video Services

The PS4 offers access to basic streaming services, including Netflix, Hulu Plus, and Amazon. The selection is as expected and should satisfy most streaming video enthusiasts.

These services can be accessed through the “TV & Video” channel on the dashboard’s home row.

The Core Experience: Gaming

Ultimately, the most compelling aspect of the PS4 is its gaming capabilities. Simply put, gaming on the PlayStation 4 is exceptional.

PS4 games are typically graphically demanding, designed to showcase the console’s power. CPU-intensive games like Civilization 5 are less common. The PS4 excels at delivering visually stunning experiences with smooth frame rates of 60 frames per second.

Determining the PS4’s full potential is challenging. Console gaming tradition suggests that it takes a year or two for developers to fully exploit a new console’s capabilities. Initial offerings often include ports of previous-generation games, such as Battlefield 4 and Call of Duty: Ghosts, which look spectacular but are still rooted in older technology.

Killzone: Shadow Fall is a visually impressive PS4-exclusive title, but it remains a launch-date game. As developers focus more on the console’s unique capabilities, the gaming experience will undoubtedly improve.

However, the visual fidelity is already remarkable – lighting, shading, textures, dust particles, and sunlight are all rendered with impressive detail. The first level of Battlefield 4 alone was captivating, prompting exploration and observation even amidst intense action.

Spending time simply observing the interplay of light and dust was a testament to the advancements in gaming technology. These subtle details highlight the progress made and hint at the future of gaming. Anyone who doubts the potential for photorealistic graphics isn’t paying attention.

While a single level of one game is just a glimpse, the PS4 delivers on its promises, and it’s poised to be a success. Having the time to fully immerse oneself in gaming, accompanied by ample snacks, would be a dream come true.

Final Thoughts: The Good, the Bad, and the Verdict

Despite responsibilities and a commitment to personal hygiene, a conclusion must be reached. How does the PS4 perform overall, and which console should you choose?

The Good:

• The 8-core processor and DDR5 memory provide ample power for years to come. Sony has equipped this console with a long lifespan, minimizing the need for frequent upgrades.
• Performance is excellent and will continue to improve with software optimizations and new game releases.
• The internal power supply eliminates the need for a bulky external power brick.
• The controller is well-designed and comfortable to use.
• The social sharing features are intuitive and integrate seamlessly with popular platforms.
• The price of $399 is competitive, offering excellent value for the hardware and features provided.
• The upgradable storage allows for expansion as game sizes increase.

The Bad:

• The PS4’s primary focus is gaming, which may be a limitation for those seeking a more versatile entertainment hub.
• The glossy finish is prone to fingerprints and scratches.
• The system menu’s home row can become cluttered and lacks customization options.
• Controller battery life is limited to 10-12 hours.
• The launch lineup of games is relatively limited.

The Verdict:

Is a recommendation warranted? Absolutely. The PS4 is an exceptional piece of hardware that delivers a fantastic gaming experience. If you can afford it, you should buy one. While initial doubts may arise, they will likely dissipate upon experiencing the console’s capabilities firsthand.

However, waiting may be beneficial. The current game selection is limited, and there may be minor hardware issues that emerge in the coming months. New console launches often experience such hiccups.

Furthermore, two other current-generation consoles are available: the Xbox One and the Wii U. Nintendo’s system has matured over the past year and boasts a substantial library of titles. For fans of Zelda and Mario, the Wii U is a compelling option. It’s also more affordable at $299, and the Wii U GamePad is a unique and innovative controller.

The Xbox One, priced at $100 more than the PS4, includes the Kinect sensor, voice control, and TV integration. In terms of specifications and performance, the Xbox One and PS4 are comparable. The choice ultimately depends on individual preferences and priorities. If gaming is your sole focus, the PS4 is the better option. If you desire a more comprehensive entertainment hub, the Xbox One may be more appealing.

Ultimately, you won’t be disappointed with either console. However, the PS4 offers the most value for your money. If I had $399 to spend, I would gladly give it to Sony.

Special thanks to SSgt Ivan Trevino (USMC) for generously loaning his new PlayStation 4 to HTG for testing and review!