Cloud Gaming: Is It the Future of Gaming?

The Evolution of Cloud Gaming

For several years, "cloud gaming" has been a prominent term within the technology sector. The core concept revolves around eliminating the necessity for high-end gaming PCs or consoles equipped with dedicated graphics processing units.

Instead, the complex computational tasks are shifted and executed remotely, "in the cloud." This paradigm shift promises accessibility and convenience for gamers.

How Cloud Gaming Functions

The operational principles of cloud gaming share significant similarities with those of video streaming services. A game is executed on a remote server, and a video feed of the gameplay is then transmitted to the user.

User interactions, such as keyboard presses, mouse movements, and controller inputs, are relayed across the network to the cloud gaming server in real-time.

The Server-Client Relationship

The remote server undertakes all the demanding processing, while the user’s device functions primarily as a receiver for the streamed video and audio output.

Simultaneously, the device transmits input commands back to the server. In essence, cloud gaming can be understood as an interactive extension of a video streaming platform.

This interactive element distinguishes it from passive video consumption, offering a dynamic gaming experience.

The Potential Benefits of Cloud Gaming

Cloud gaming presents a number of compelling advantages in principle.

Reduced Hardware Costs and Eliminated Upgrade Cycles - A key benefit of cloud gaming is the removal of the need for frequent and costly hardware upgrades. Instead of investing in a powerful gaming PC or console, users can leverage their existing devices. Alternatively, a low-cost streaming device and controller can provide access via a television and network connection.
Cross-Platform Gaming Accessibility - Currently, many high-performance games are limited to PC (typically Windows) or console platforms. Cloud gaming has the potential to break down these barriers, enabling play on a wider range of operating systems including Mac, Linux, Android, iOS, Chrome OS, and Windows RT.
Seamless Integration with Smart TVs and Other Devices - Television manufacturers could directly incorporate cloud gaming service support into their smart TV offerings. This would eliminate the need for dedicated gaming hardware within the TV itself, allowing any compatible TV with the appropriate software and a controller to function as a gaming platform. Some smart TVs already demonstrate this capability through integrations like OnLive.
Immediate Gameplay Access - Traditional game installations can require substantial downloads, often ranging from 10GB to 20GB or more. Cloud gaming bypasses this requirement, allowing users to begin playing games instantly, as the game is already installed and running on the server.
Simplified Game Spectating - Cloud gaming facilitates effortless spectating of gaming events, such as professional esports competitions. Spectators would not need to install the game locally, as the video stream can be readily distributed to numerous viewers.
Enhanced Digital Rights Management (DRM) - Running games on remote servers rather than local computers significantly reduces the risk of piracy. This aspect makes cloud gaming an appealing DRM solution for publishers, though its appeal may differ among gamers.

The potential for streamlined spectating and robust DRM are further advantages.

htg-explains-what-is-cloud-gaming-and-is-it-the-future-1.jpg

Drawbacks of Cloud Gaming

Despite its advantages, cloud gaming presents several notable disadvantages that users should consider.

Image Compression - Similar to streaming video platforms like YouTube and Netflix, cloud gaming relies on compressing the game's visual data to reduce bandwidth consumption. This compression inevitably results in a loss of visual fidelity compared to a game rendered natively on a powerful gaming PC. However, the quality of the compressed stream can sometimes exceed that of a locally rendered game at lower settings.
Internet Bandwidth Requirements - Utilizing cloud gaming services demands substantial internet bandwidth. For instance, a single hour of gameplay on a service like OnLive can consume over 3GB of data. This poses a significant challenge for users with data caps or limited internet plans. Widespread adoption of cloud gaming would substantially increase overall internet traffic.
Input Lag - A fundamental limitation of cloud gaming is the inherent latency. Games respond more rapidly to player input when processed locally. The time it takes for actions to register – from mouse movements to rendering and transmission – is always greater when relying on a remote server and internet connection.
Digital Rights Management (DRM) Concerns - While publishers appreciate the DRM benefits offered by cloud gaming, this approach could disadvantage many gamers. Similar to the issues faced by players in areas with poor internet connectivity attempting to play always-online games like Diablo 3, cloud gaming's stringent internet requirements could create accessibility barriers.

The reliance on a stable and high-speed internet connection remains a critical factor impacting the overall cloud gaming experience.

The Current Landscape of Cloud Gaming

A number of cloud gaming platforms are presently available to consumers. Among these, OnLive has garnered significant attention, though reports suggest a relatively modest user base, peaking at approximately 1800 concurrent users prior to its restructuring in August 2012.

Despite not matching the performance of a dedicated gaming PC or console, OnLive delivers a surprisingly functional experience given the substantial technological hurdles involved. While latency and image compression are perceptible, their impact is less severe than many anticipate.

Individuals interested in evaluating the service can download the OnLive client, which is compatible with Windows, macOS, Android, select smart TVs, and the dedicated OnLive Game System hardware. A full-version "free trial" of each supported game is offered for a 30-minute period, providing ample opportunity to assess OnLive’s capabilities.

OnLive faced strong competition from Gaikai, a company that leveraged its technology to offer streaming game demos directly within a web browser. This provided a more accessible method for game evaluation, eliminating the need for lengthy downloads.

However, Gaikai was acquired by Sony in July 2012 for $380 million, and its streaming demos are no longer operational. Sony is expected to integrate Gaikai’s technology into its own offerings.

Potential Sony Applications of Gaikai

Speculation suggests Sony may utilize Gaikai to provide instant streaming demos for PlayStation 4 games. This would allow players to experience games before purchase without the need for downloads.

Further rumors propose that Gaikai could facilitate the streaming of PlayStation 3 games, effectively offering backwards compatibility on the PS4, even without native PS3 support on the console itself.

The Potential of Cloud Gaming

Despite initial struggles, exemplified by the user base of OnLive, cloud gaming continues to attract significant interest from major industry players. Sony’s acquisition of Gaikai serves as a clear indication of this ongoing investment.

Currently, NVIDIA is developing Project Shield, a handheld gaming console powered by Android. This device is designed to stream PC games from a user’s computer, provided the PC is equipped with a sufficiently powerful NVIDIA graphics card. This approach enables a single gaming PC to wirelessly power gameplay on both a handheld console and a television.

Reduced latency is a key benefit, as streaming occurs over a local network. Furthermore, bandwidth limitations become less of a concern when the connection remains entirely within the user’s home network. NVIDIA appears confident in this model, which aims to deliver the advantages of cloud gaming while mitigating some of its inherent drawbacks – contingent upon possessing robust PC gaming hardware.

Valve’s Perspective

Valve, the company behind the widely-used Steam platform, holds a different view on the future of gaming. Gabe Newell, the head of Valve, has articulated his thoughts on the matter:

“If the gaming industry had never embraced consoles or dedicated client software, even a cloud-centric start would inevitably lead to distributing processing power towards the network’s edge. This strategy optimizes caching and minimizes network resource consumption.”

Essentially, Newell suggests that a purely cloud-based gaming landscape would naturally evolve towards localized gaming solutions due to the inherent benefits of the latter.

The OnLive gaming system, a streaming-only platform, is priced at $99 including a controller. However, the upcoming Ouya console, which supports both local and cloud-based gaming via OnLive, offers greater versatility at the same price point. As the cost of local gaming hardware continues to decrease, the appeal of cloud gaming diminishes.

Looking Ahead

Predicting the future remains an uncertain endeavor. While OnLive has not supplanted traditional gaming PCs or consoles, Sony’s substantial $380 million investment in cloud gaming suggests potential integration of these features into the PS4.

Similar to how tablets have not rendered the PC obsolete, cloud gaming is unlikely to eliminate local gaming in the near future. However, it may present a viable alternative in specific scenarios.

Image Credit: JD Hancock on Flickr, NVIDIA