Crypto Volatility: Why Wall Street is Confused

Crypto Markets and Wall Street's Struggles

The cryptocurrency market presents both opportunities and challenges, often leaving traditional Wall Street investors perplexed.

Following Coinbase’s recent earnings release, the company’s stock price has experienced a significant decline this morning.

Understanding the Volatility

The core issue stems from public market investors consistently misjudging the inherent volatility of the crypto space.

This leads to both excessive optimism during periods of growth and disproportionate pessimism when results are less spectacular.

The Exchange provides insights into startups, markets, and financial matters.

Access it daily on TechCrunch+ or subscribe to The Exchange newsletter each Saturday.

Coinbase isn't isolated in this pattern of initial excitement followed by investor disappointment.

Robinhood recently reported similar results, with a decrease in its share price linked to reduced crypto trading volumes.

Pre-Report Warnings and Investor Reactions

Both Coinbase and Robinhood had previously indicated that their crypto-related revenue would decrease in the third quarter of 2021 compared to the second.

Despite these warnings, public investors still appeared taken aback when the anticipated decline materialized.

The Pace of Crypto Innovation

The rapid evolution of the cryptocurrency ecosystem may simply be outpacing the ability of public market investors to fully comprehend its dynamics.

Furthermore, even crypto exchanges themselves aren't the most volatile investments within the broader crypto landscape.

A deeper examination of these factors is warranted.

Fluctuating Fortunes: Crypto Revenue Declines at Robinhood and Coinbase

Robinhood experienced a significant decrease in crypto trading revenue, falling from $233 million in Q2 2021 to $51 million in the third quarter. While the company had previously cautioned investors about an anticipated slowdown, the extent of the decline may have surpassed Wall Street’s expectations.

It’s important to remember that Robinhood had informed investors during its initial public offering (IPO) process that sequential revenue decreases were expected in Q3. This was attributed to reduced trading activity compared to the record highs, particularly in cryptocurrencies, observed during the quarter ending June 30, 2021.

Despite this prior communication, investor reaction was one of surprise.

A comparable trend is evident at Coinbase, which also predicted lower retail monthly transacting users and overall trading volume in Q3 compared to Q2 in its Q2 earnings report. This prediction proved accurate, yet the market still expressed shock.

According to CNBC, Coinbase’s Q3 revenues reached $1.31 billion, falling short of the anticipated $1.57 billion. Consequently, Coinbase shares experienced an approximately 8% drop this morning.

Both Robinhood and Coinbase maintain strong financial positions and are in stable condition. The Q3 results, while falling short of market expectations, serve as a learning opportunity for investors rather than indicating corporate failure. However, these warnings, subsequent results, and the resulting investor losses are demonstrative of a key issue.

Specifically, they highlight Wall Street’s continued underestimation of the inherent volatility within the cryptocurrency market, despite its increasing maturity. This volatility is not diminishing.

NFT Market Volatility

Consider OpenSea, a leading NFT marketplace. Its trading data reveals multiple cycles of boom and bust within the NFT space during this year alone. DappRadar data shows peaks in trading volume in August and October, followed by substantial declines in subsequent months. This pattern isn’t seasonal; it reflects a highly variable market.

Therefore, if Wall Street struggles to comprehend the lack of consistent revenue growth from broader exchanges, anticipate similar reactions when public NFT exchanges report results such as “Q3 trading volumes decreased due to falling NFT prices and reduced investor interest in specific collections, including Bold Badgers Squad and SolChicks.”

These factors should be incorporated into financial projections.

This isn’t a criticism of either Coinbase or Robinhood. Both companies remain compelling businesses, and their value extends beyond recent trading incomes. Interestingly, Wall Street’s difficulty in understanding the crypto economy’s volatility actually positions these two companies as strong – and somewhat ironic – indicators of the overall crypto market.

In simpler terms, purchasing Coinbase shares can be a viable method for gaining exposure to the crypto world. Its revenues closely mirror the fluctuations in broader crypto market volume and, consequently, crypto prices. Given the public market’s apparent discomfort with the unpredictability of crypto results, Coinbase stock exhibits a dynamic behavior reminiscent of a cryptocurrency itself.

While Coinbase won’t achieve the same exponential gains as a speculative “shitcoin,” its stock performance is notably volatile. According to Yahoo Finance data, Coinbase has traded within a historical range of $208.00 to $429.54 per share. This is highly characteristic of the crypto market.

Thus, Coinbase stock currently serves as a reasonable proxy for direct crypto exposure, largely due to its results and the public market’s tendency to overreact to short-term fluctuations. The same may be true for Robinhood. It remains to be seen how long it will take for Wall Street to fully acknowledge this reality.