Founder Vesting Schedules: Solving the Dead Equity Problem

Editor’s note: Receive a complimentary weekly summary of TechCrunch news relevant to all startups delivered via email each Saturday morning (7 a.m. PT). Sign up here.

The standard four-year vesting period commonly utilized by startups today presents a potential issue down the line. Should a founder decide to leave the company a year or two before the final vesting milestone, they could retain a substantial portion of the company’s equity through subsequent funding rounds. While the departing founder may view this as equitable, the remaining founder(s) are responsible for generating further value – and this situation can breed discontent, among other concerns.

“The cost of unearned equity translates to lost talent and investment,” explains Jake Jolis of Matrix Partners in a guest contribution this week. “Attracting skilled personnel and securing funding are the sole purposes of a startup’s equity, and both are essential for growth. Building a successful, large-scale business requires a lengthy and challenging journey, demanding all the support you can obtain. If your rivals aren’t burdened with unvested equity, you’re effectively competing at a disadvantage.”

He proposes that startups in their initial stages should explore extending the vesting schedule to eight years. As an illustration, a founder who leaves after two and a half years under a four-year plan could hold onto 22% of the company, even following a significant new funding round, the establishment of an employee stock option pool, and the allocation of shares for a new co-founder-level employee. With an eight-year plan, this figure would be reduced to just 11%, creating a more attractive incentive for potential co-founders.

The complete article is available on Extra Crunch, but I am sharing additional key excerpts here due to its widespread relevance:

Finally, reflecting on my own experience as a startup co-founder, a departing co-founder will naturally desire the company’s success to maximize the value of their equity. On the challenging path between failure and achievement in this industry, extending the vesting period is a valuable method to ensure the company delivers the greatest possible return to them following the initial hard work.

The Reasoning Behind a Leading Early-Stage VC Firm's Entry into the SPAC Market

Special Purpose Acquisition Companies (SPACs) represent a compelling opportunity for investors of all kinds, whether they participate in public or private markets, according to Amish Jani from FirstMark Capital, in a discussion with Connie Loizos. Traditionally, his firm has concentrated on making investments in companies during their initial phases of growth. Therefore, it may seem unexpected that FirstMark Horizon Acquisition, a SPAC launched by the firm, successfully secured $360 million in funding and is now actively seeking a promising unicorn-status company to acquire. However, he provides a thorough explanation of this strategic shift during a detailed conversation this week:

He further elaborates on the factors suggesting that the public markets will likely remain favorable for well-positioned SPACs for a considerable period.

The complete interview can be found on TechCrunch.

SaaS growth persists with Databricks investment, Segment purchase

Segment likely would have pursued an initial public offering in the near future, however Twilio has acquired the company this week for $3.2 billion. The widely-used data management platform will now integrate into Twilio’s growing collection of customer engagement solutions. This acquisition could indicate a period of industry consolidation following a significant surge in new SaaS companies over the past ten years. Alex Wilhelm analyzed the financial details of the transaction for Extra Crunch and concluded the price wasn’t excessive – he even suggests Segment potentially could have negotiated a higher valuation, particularly given the increase in Twilio’s stock value this year.

Databricks has transitioned from an open-source data analytics platform with initial revenue challenges to achieving a $350 million annual revenue run rate. According to an interview Alex conducted for Extra Crunch with CEO Ali Ghodsi, this expansion resulted from a strategic focus on proprietary code, attracting large enterprise clients, and developing advanced capabilities. The company is currently planning to launch an IPO in the coming year.

Regarding the IPO market, which experienced a slower week, Alex assigned a performance grade to each of the 18 most prominent technology companies that have gone public this year, noting that the majority continue to trade above their initial offering prices.

Nigeria startup scene gets watershed exit with Paystack deal

For several years, Lagos has been fostering a thriving local startup ecosystem, and this week witnessed a significant achievement that could signal a turning point for the city, the nation, and the wider region. Stripe has reached an agreement to purchase payments company Paystack in a transaction reportedly exceeding $200 million, as reported by Ingrid Lunden. Given Stripe’s plans for a substantial initial public offering, Paystack is well-positioned to generate continued profits for the company and its stakeholders, while also cultivating a new wave of investors, entrepreneurs, and highly qualified personnel in Nigeria with strong connections to Silicon Valley and other leading innovation hubs.

A single, or a couple of, impactful transactions can fundamentally transform a startup hub. Those following industry news around the time Google acquired YouTube – almost exactly 14 years ago – will recall the subsequent increase in funding rounds, new company launches, acquisitions, and overall activity within the consumer internet sector, which played a key role in revitalizing the Silicon Valley internet landscape (and also contributed to the growth of this publication). Stripe has indicated its intention to pursue further international growth, potentially through additional acquisitions of this nature, suggesting that other cities globally may soon experience similar breakthroughs.

Vienna startups discovering fresh possibilities amidst the pandemic

This week’s European investor survey for Extra Crunch features insights from Mike Butcher, who examines the recent increase in startup growth within Vienna, Austria. Below is commentary from Eva Ahr of Capital 300, an investment firm concentrating on Germanic and Central Eastern European ventures, concerning the pandemic’s effects on regional markets:

Mike is currently preparing a survey focused on Lisbon, and we welcome input from any investors specializing in the city and Portugal as a whole.

TechCrunch Highlights

Explore a conversation regarding the shifting landscape of venture capital funding for startups, featuring Sarah Leary and John Vrionis from Unusual Ventures and their perspectives on the trend of specialized, early-stage investment.

Across the week

TechCrunch:

For the advertising sector to genuinely prioritize openness, making the source code for our Software Development Kits publicly available is a crucial step.

Brazil’s growing tech hub, often referred to as Black Silicon Valley, has the potential to become a major center for new ideas and advancements throughout Latin America.

As worldwide interest in artificial intelligence increases, South Korea is actively promoting the development of AI-focused semiconductor technology.

Achieving genuine fairness in how equity is distributed as compensation is a critical requirement.

The most recent restrictions on immigration enacted by Donald Trump are likely to have negative consequences for the American workforce.

Extra Crunch:

The COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent economic downturn are having a noticeable effect on women who are launching their own businesses.

Entrepreneurs are establishing communal living arrangements for developers, aiming to replicate the collaborative atmosphere found in Silicon Valley.

Alex Latsis of Brighteye Ventures discusses the trends in funding for European educational technology companies during the year 2020.

An individual who entered the country on a B-1 visa and was then affected by the COVID-19 pandemic is seeking guidance on options for remaining in the country.

The release of the iPhone 12 provides insights into the current condition and future direction of the smartphone market in 2020.

#EquityPod

From Alex:

Greetings and welcome to another episode of Equity, TechCrunch’s podcast dedicated to the world of venture capital (and now available on Twitter!), where we analyze the data behind the latest industry developments.

The entire team rejoined today, as Natasha, Danny, and I came together to discuss a significant wave of recent news. Numerous startups are securing funding, a considerable number of venture capital firms are raising capital, and several unicorn companies are preparing for initial public offerings. There’s a great deal to cover, but we’re here to provide you with a comprehensive update.

Here’s a summary of the topics we explored:

• News from the Media Landscape: Juggernaut successfully completed a $2 million funding round, a development we considered both interesting and relevant. This news regarding a media startup’s funding was accompanied by reports suggesting a potential acquisition of the popular email newsletter Morning Brew for a valuation reaching as high as $75 million. These stories were further contextualized by recent reports highlighting the financial success Axios is currently experiencing. It’s encouraging to share positive news from the media sector, especially in contrast to recent reports of workforce reductions.
• Investment in Wellness Startups: If you’re interested in improving your mental and physical well-being, this was a noteworthy week for related news. Calm is actively seeking additional investment at an increased valuation. TechCrunch provides further details here. Coa successfully raised, receiving $3 million to expand its mental health group class offerings. Additionally, Playbook secured $9.3 million for its platform connecting users with fitness instructors.
• Venture Capital Firms Securing Funding: This is a particularly active period for venture capital firms themselves to raise capital, with OpenView, Canaan, True Ventures, Lead Edge Capital, First Round and Khosla having either finalized funding rounds or announced plans for new fundraises.
• Updates in the Venture Capital Space: Terri Burns has been promoted to investing partner at GV.
• Finally, we discussed the latest funding round and subsequent turnaround efforts at GetAround which led to a conversation about Airbnb’s own path to recovery. TechCrunch has additional coverage available here.

That concludes our discussion for now. We’ll be back on Monday morning. We look forward to connecting with you again soon, and wish you continued good health and safety.