iBooks vs Kindle: Which eBook Platform is Best for iPad Users?
Revisiting the iPad as an eBook Reader: iBooks vs. Kindle
Previously, I explored resources for obtaining free books on the iPad. In a prior assessment, I contrasted the iPad with dedicated eReader devices, concluding that it didn't quite measure up as a replacement.
However, after considering feedback, I re-evaluated the iPad's capabilities as a standard eBook platform and discovered a surprisingly positive user experience.
Choosing an eBook Platform: iBooks or Kindle?
During my investigation, the central question became which platform offered the superior reading experience: Apple's iBooks or Amazon's Kindle for iPad.
While alternative readers like Stanza exist, this comparison will concentrate specifically on iBooks and the Kindle app.
The following analysis aims to determine which of these two platforms – iBooks or Kindle – is the better choice for iPad users.
Ultimately, the ideal platform depends on individual preferences and existing eBook ecosystems.
iBooks
The iBooks application is available for free download from the app store and is frequently among the initial applications installed on a new iDevice.
This displays the standard library interface within iBooks. Its design is highly visual and reminiscent of a traditional library, creating a genuine sensation of possessing physical books.
The library offers search functionality with live updates as you type, providing immediate results. Books can be easily sorted and removed, allowing for personalized library management. The process is both direct and user-friendly.
To begin reading, books are essential. Within iBooks, a built-in store provides access to a wide selection of both free and paid titles. Additionally, ePub and PDF files can be downloaded and imported through iTunes or via email for seamless access.
The ability to incorporate PDFs is a valuable asset, and the library can be organized by collections – books, PDFs, or any other desired categorization.
The reading experience in iBooks aims to replicate a physical book, complete with simulated "pages." Pages are turned by tapping the corresponding side of the screen, though each turn is accompanied by an animation. While page turning is generally responsive, initial app loading can sometimes feel slightly delayed.
These are the default settings with which iBooks launches. These initial configurations were not particularly appealing:
Following some adjustments, a more enjoyable reading experience was achieved. Several fonts and two font sizes are available, along with options to enable Sepia mode and adjust brightness. The menu icons remain visible unless specifically hidden by tapping the page.
Searching within a book is straightforward, and the results are highly focused. Limited contextual information accompanies each result. Selecting a result directs you to the corresponding page, with the search term highlighted.
During reading, a long tap on any word reveals options to copy, define in a dictionary, highlight, add a note, or search for the word within the book. The highlighting effect closely resembles that of a physical marker!
Pages can be bookmarked for easy access through the table of contents, where bookmarks, highlights, and notes are also conveniently located.
Kindle for iPad: A Comprehensive Overview
The Kindle application for iPad is available as a complimentary download through the app store. It can be utilized alongside a dedicated Kindle device, or employed as a standalone e-reading solution.
The primary library interface presents a dark and visually appealing aesthetic, evoking a classic eBook experience.
Accessing eBooks requires registration with a valid Kindle account. Upon registration, your existing library will synchronize, granting you access to all previously purchased titles.
Additional books can be acquired through the Amazon store, or by downloading .mobi formatted files. A convenient method for importing these files involves emailing them to your personal email address. Within the Kindle app, your archived items are also accessible for easy download to your iPad. A direct search function within the library itself was not discovered.
The default reading mode is characterized by its minimalism. It is a clean and uncluttered experience. Menu icons are dynamically hidden for an immersive view, and the concept of "pages" is absent. Page turns are initiated with a gentle tap on the screen, and the page-turn animation can be disabled if desired. Essentially, it presents a simple white screen displaying text.
Further customization is possible through the application’s settings. Users can select from three distinct background types, and adjust the font size with six available options. However, the font style itself remains fixed and cannot be altered.
Searching for specific terms within a book is both rapid and efficient, providing contextual information for each result. Selecting a search result will navigate you directly to the corresponding location within the text.
A prolonged tap on any word reveals options to highlight the selection, add a personal note, or share it via social media platforms like Twitter or Facebook. An automatic dictionary definition is also displayed at the bottom of the screen.
The functionality of the sharing feature was investigated, but resulted in a "Sharing not supported" error message. The conditions under which sharing is enabled remain unclear.
Bookmarks, highlights, and notes are readily accessible by tapping the book icon and navigating to the My Notes & Marks section.
A particularly valuable feature of Kindle for iPad is the ability to switch to a white-on-black color scheme. Furthermore, the font size can be significantly increased. This allows for comfortable nighttime reading without the need for additional lighting, preventing disturbance to others. This is a significant benefit. (Refer to this post for similar functionality within iBooks).
Final Thoughts
When acquiring new reading material, iBooks presents a slight convenience – the elimination of the need for an additional account. Its interface is also remarkably streamlined and intuitive, complemented by excellent library management and annotation capabilities.
However, regarding the actual act of reading, the Kindle consistently emerges as my preferred choice. The uncluttered presentation, displaying solely the text, provides an unparalleled reading experience.
Furthermore, the functionality for nighttime reading truly embodies technological advancement.
What are your preferences? Or perhaps you favor a different e-reader? Please share your thoughts in the comments section below.
Image source: Shutterstock
