Google OnHub Review: Wi-Fi & Smarthome Integration
Google OnHub Router: A Comprehensive Review
Google has entered the competitive market for routers and smarthome devices with the launch of the OnHub router.
This new device aims to deliver an exceptionally user-friendly and streamlined networking experience.
Key Features and Promises
The OnHub router is designed to simplify network management, offering features like incredibly easy setup procedures.
Automatic security updates are also a core component, ensuring your network remains protected without manual intervention.
Furthermore, the OnHub boasts seamless smarthome integration, expanding its functionality beyond traditional routing.
Does the OnHub Deliver?
The central question is whether the OnHub successfully fulfills its ambitious promises of simplicity and convenience.
Initial impressions suggest a significant effort has been made to create a router that minimizes technical complexities for the average user.
The integration with other smarthome products is intended to create a more connected and automated home environment.
Simplified Setup and Management
One of the primary selling points of the OnHub is its remarkably straightforward setup process.
Traditional router configurations can often be daunting, but Google has strived to eliminate this barrier to entry.
The router is also designed to manage itself, reducing the need for constant monitoring and adjustments.
Security and Updates
Maintaining network security is paramount, and the OnHub addresses this with its automatic update system.
These updates are applied in the background, protecting against emerging threats without requiring user intervention.
This proactive approach to security is a significant advantage over routers that rely on manual updates.
Smarthome Compatibility
The OnHub’s smarthome integration allows it to work seamlessly with a variety of compatible devices.
This connectivity enables users to control and manage their smart home ecosystem directly through the router.
The potential for expanded functionality and automation is a key benefit of this feature.
What is the Google OnHub?
The Google OnHub represents Google’s initial venture into the market for home routers and home automation hubs. It’s important to note, however, that this isn’t Google’s first foray into smart home technology, as they had previously acquired both Nest and Dropcam.
This device, built to Google’s specifications by TP-Link, a renowned networking company, presents a unique design compared to conventional routers. It features a cylindrical form factor and lacks external antennas.
Unlike many recently reviewed routers, such as the Netgear Nighthawk X6 or the D-Link DIR-890L, the OnHub doesn’t resemble a futuristic insect or spacecraft. Instead, its aesthetic is more akin to a minimalist speaker – a comparison frequently made by those who have seen it.
Design and Purpose
The cylindrical shape isn’t merely a stylistic decision; it’s integral to Google’s objectives for the OnHub. A primary benefit of the OnHub is its simplicity and powerful performance, designed for central placement within the home to optimize Wi-Fi coverage.
Consequently, the OnHub is designed to be visually unobtrusive, blending seamlessly into a home environment. While aesthetic preferences vary, it generally appears more refined than traditional routers adorned with LEDs and protruding antennas.
The circular arrangement of antennas, illustrated in the product diagram below, facilitates omni-directional Wi-Fi broadcasting.
Technical Specifications
The device incorporates a 2.4Ghz 3x3 array and a 5GHz 3x3 array. Additionally, it includes an auxiliary 2.4Ghz 1x1 array dedicated to monitoring network congestion, a feature we will explore further.
Beyond ease of setup and superior Wi-Fi coverage, the OnHub automatically receives security updates. This is a significant advantage, considering the prevalence of router security vulnerabilities and the infrequent manual updates performed by users.
Physical Ports and Connectivity
Before detailing the setup process, let's examine the physical ports located on the router. Removing the outer shroud reveals a minimalist layout: one gigabit Ethernet input, one gigabit Ethernet output, a power port, and a USB port.
The USB port is currently disabled but will be enabled through future firmware updates. The device also contains additional radios for home automation functionality: Bluetooth and ZigBee/Thread.
These radios are expected to be activated in subsequent firmware releases to enable connectivity with smart home devices. An ambient light sensor and a 3-watt speaker are also integrated into the OnHub, further indicating Google’s vision for a combined router/home automation hub.
Interestingly, the device lacks an integrated microphone, unlike the Amazon Echo. While a microphone was initially anticipated for voice command functionality, its absence is arguably a privacy benefit.
Availability and Pricing
The OnHub is available in jet black or a deep navy blue color. It has a retail price of $199. However, at the time of this publication, obtaining one proves challenging due to widespread stock shortages.
Initial Setup of the Google OnHub
The process of configuring the Google OnHub is straightforward, though it presents an initial adjustment for experienced users. The primary challenge isn't technical difficulty, but rather a shift in the traditional setup method. Unlike conventional routers, initial configuration doesn't utilize a web browser.
Instead of accessing a configuration portal through a web browser – such as the typical http://192.168.0.1 address – Google employs a dedicated smartphone application for iOS and Android devices. While it’s probable that purchasers of this premium router possess a compatible mobile device, this design choice remains somewhat unconventional. Ideally, the OnHub would offer both a smartphone app and a web-based interface for local computer access.
However, once this initial mental adjustment is made, the router setup proves remarkably simple. The setup process begins by downloading the "Google On" application (available on both iOS and Android app stores), installing it, and then following the guided instructions.
The application prompts you to select the Google account for management purposes. A clear tutorial then guides you through the physical connections and optimal placement of the router. Subsequently, you connect wirelessly to the OnHub to finalize the configuration.
Those familiar with smart home device setup will recognize this procedure. Your smartphone connects directly to the router (operating in a temporary Wi-Fi ad-hoc mode), allowing you to configure settings before a final restart.
Advanced users may find the customization options limited. Google prioritizes ease of use and robust Wi-Fi coverage with the OnHub. Consequently, the configuration process primarily involves selecting a network name (SSID), establishing a password, and potentially making minor adjustments – such as static IP assignments or port forwarding – after the router restarts with the new network information.
Users accustomed to navigating complex router control panels, or even customized firmware like DD-WRT, will find the OnHub experience exceptionally streamlined. The interface offers minimal toggles and straightforward options, completing the setup in a matter of minutes. The trade-off for this simplicity, however, is the absence of advanced features that often require more involved configuration.
Exploring the Unique Capabilities of the OnHub
During our evaluation of numerous routers at How-To Geek, the "Specialty Features" segment typically involves a detailed examination of functions like print server setups, storage attachments, and parental control options.
However, our assessment of the OnHub diverges from this standard approach in several ways. Firstly, the OnHub lacks many conventional specialty features. There’s currently no dedicated parental control interface, and USB functionality remains unavailable despite the presence of a port. Consequently, we cannot demonstrate network drive or printer connections. Furthermore, the smart home networking capabilities, powered by Zigbee/Thread radios, are presently inactive. Secondly, the OnHub’s most significant strengths are largely imperceptible to the user, as they are engineered for automation and ease of use. While we can describe these features, direct user access or observation is limited.
Nevertheless, let's proceed with an exploration of the OnHub’s features, beginning with those that are directly accessible and interactive for the user.
Integrated Speed Testing
This feature stood out as our most favored aspect of the OnHub. It incorporates a built-in speed test that proves remarkably practical. Beyond simply measuring upload and download speeds, the test also assesses signal strength and your physical proximity to the router.
You receive not only upload/download data but also a Wi-Fi signal strength reading, accompanied by an explanation of why your speeds are performing as they are. This feature prompted us to consider why such functionality isn’t standard in modern router interfaces. We would welcome its inclusion in other routers: on-router speed testing with Wi-Fi strength feedback when the test is conducted wirelessly.
Simplified Credential Sharing
Another convenient feature is the integrated system for sharing your Wi-Fi credentials. Whether a friend is present or will be house-sitting in the future, sharing credentials is exceptionally easy via any sharing method supported by your phone (AirDrop, email, text messaging, etc.).
As shown in the center panel above, the router provides a straightforward way to display the password for easy copying. While seemingly minor, this contributes to the overall frictionless user experience Google aims to deliver, and we value this effort.
Remote Management
Remote access is a common feature in nearly all routers. However, the OnHub differentiates itself by authorizing remote access through a Google account and the OnHub app, rather than solely through the router’s external IP address. Whether you are away from home or managing the OnHub for a family member, you can utilize the same setup app for control.
Although control options are limited, the remote access experience is remarkably smooth and user-friendly.
Minimalist Status Indicator
While some prefer elaborate indicator lights, most users find them distracting. The OnHub replaces the complex light displays found on many routers with a simple, understated light ring around the top. A solid blue/green indicates normal operation, while a slow orange blink signals network issues.
Considering how infrequently router lights are actually monitored, this shift towards easily understandable ambient information is welcome. You can quickly assess the router’s status from across the room.
Furthermore, the brightness of the indicator ring can be adjusted within the control application to ensure it’s visible without being intrusive.
Automated Channel Selection
One of the primary causes of poor Wi-Fi performance on the 2.4GHz band is channel interference. The channels within the 2.4GHz band often overlap, and using a channel close to a neighbor’s can reduce network effectiveness. This issue is compounded in densely populated areas.
The OnHub utilizes an additional 2.4GHz antenna solely for testing and diagnostics, in addition to its three antennas for data transmission. This antenna analyzes the local 2.4GHz spectrum and automatically switches channels without user intervention.
This dedicated antenna and automatic detection represent a significant improvement over manual channel adjustments and even the “auto” function found on some routers lacking a dedicated antenna.
Initially skeptical, we tested the function by introducing interference from nearby routers and monitoring the process. We found it to be remarkably smooth and fully automated.
Automatic Software Updates
Beyond the simple user interface, the most compelling benefit of the OnHub is its automatic update system. Google rightly emphasizes the importance of keeping routers updated to address security vulnerabilities. Millions of routers worldwide are running outdated firmware, posing a significant risk.
Google’s solution is to deliver frequent, automatic security updates to the OnHub without user input, preserving settings and functioning seamlessly, similar to updates on platforms like iOS.
While we haven’t yet observed the update process due to the router’s recent release, Google claims it won’t disrupt connectivity and will be largely unnoticeable. We remain hopeful that this claim holds true.
Router Performance and Evaluation
The pursuit of enhanced performance has become a central focus in the router market. Currently, the routers we evaluate consistently meet our requirements, providing comprehensive Wi-Fi coverage throughout a typical home. Beyond rigorous benchmark testing, discernible differences in real-world usage are often negligible.
Indeed, one could argue that performance benchmarking is becoming somewhat repetitive. The marginal gains – such as a vehicle reaching 225MPH versus 220MPH – seem inconsequential when most driving occurs at lower speeds for everyday tasks.
Nevertheless, we conducted benchmark tests on the OnHub, comparing its results to those of previously reviewed routers, including the D-Link DIR-890L. Did it outperform top-tier routers in a direct comparison? The answer is no. In certain areas, it was unable to compete, primarily due to the current lack of network-attached storage capabilities for testing client-to-router speeds.
However, the crucial question remains: is this a significant drawback? We believe it is not. The router market is approaching a saturation point where, barring substantial design flaws, routers generally surpass the needs of most users, much like high-performance sports cars exceeding the requirements of daily commuting.
The OnHub delivers substantial speed. When positioned centrally within our test environment, it fully utilized our broadband connection in 80% of the house, and nearly maximized it in the remaining 20%. Wi-Fi signal strength even extended to areas where connectivity isn't typically required, such as a considerable distance from the property.
While the OnHub may not offer advanced features favored by power users – such as multiple USB 3.0 ports – its speed is more than adequate. The unique radial design, incorporating multiple internal antennas, effectively broadcasts the signal.
A Comprehensive Review of the Google OnHub
Following initial setup, performance benchmarking, and extended daily use, a thorough evaluation of the OnHub router has been conducted. This assessment details its strengths, weaknesses, and ultimately, provides a considered verdict.
Positive Attributes
- The device boasts an aesthetically pleasing design. Google intentionally designed it for open display, and its appearance is certainly agreeable.
- Wi-Fi coverage and data transfer speeds are remarkably strong. Broadband capacity is likely to be the limiting factor long before the OnHub reaches its performance limits.
- An integrated speed test and Wi-Fi signal strength indicator prove to be exceptionally useful tools.
- Despite initial concerns regarding its simplicity, the application-based user interface is remarkably intuitive and easy to navigate.
- Sharing network credentials and enabling remote access are streamlined and exceptionally user-friendly processes.
Areas for Improvement
- While the design encourages open placement, many users will prefer to conceal their networking equipment, potentially requiring cable extensions or relocation of existing hardware.
- Advanced configuration options are notably absent. Setting static IP addresses and configuring port forwarding are restricted, and more sophisticated features are not currently available.
- Several features remain inactive or unsupported at this time, including integrated home automation radios and the USB port. A web-based router management portal, previously announced, is also currently unavailable.
- The single Ethernet port necessitates additional networking hardware for users requiring multiple wired connections.
- The price point is comparable to current-generation premium routers, despite lacking a comparable suite of advanced features.
Final Assessment
Forming a definitive conclusion regarding the OnHub presents a challenge, as it currently feels like an incomplete product. Google positions the OnHub as a forward-thinking router, equipped with ample storage and hardware designed for future functionality. However, the currently disabled features are arguably essential now.
The inclusion of a USB port is not a futuristic consideration; it represents established technology that users expect in the present. Similarly, home automation capabilities are current demands, and it is perplexing why Google did not launch a product with comprehensive home automation integration. What is the rationale behind this delayed implementation?
Google already possesses Nest, Dropcam, and is actively developing a home automation ecosystem. Why wasn't the router released in a fully functional state, incorporating these features from the outset? We are not seeking these features in a future update or a subsequent OnHub iteration; we desire them immediately.
It may seem critical to emphasize this point, but it is a valid concern. If the sole requirement is a basic router, the OnHub's $200 price tag may not be justified. It is a competent router, undeniably user-friendly. In fact, for individuals or family members seeking a powerful yet straightforward router, it may represent the best balance of power and simplicity currently available.
However, if a more feature-rich router is desired, $200 can secure a device with greater capabilities. Therefore, our verdict is as follows: if a router with the most intuitive interface, automatic channel selection, and reliable security updates is paramount, the OnHub is a suitable choice. You will receive a robust, maintenance-free networking solution.
If, however, the appeal of the OnHub lies in its potential for integration with home automation systems, we recommend postponing purchase. Observe future updates or await the release of a revised OnHub 2.0. We anticipate that once these issues are resolved, the product will be truly exceptional, but currently, we are somewhat disappointed by Google's decision to release a router with so many unrealized features.