Gillmor Gang: Time Delay - Tech Podcast Discussion

Navigating Complexities in the Current Landscape

Articulating our perspectives on the present situation presents a challenge. Words flow readily, each carefully chosen to reflect the significance of the issues confronting us. It’s conceivable that this initial section may be revised as clarity emerges.

Considerations of mandates, the circumstances surrounding the Olympics, and the evolution of events over the past two weeks are all relevant. Let's analyze these factors, setting aside discussions of former President Trump and the political maneuvering hindering the passage of the bipartisan infrastructure bill. We will also avoid dwelling on ambiguities and incomplete statements, focusing instead on the point where discussion yields tangible results.

Acknowledging Courage and Accountability

Recognition is due to the courageous athletes who prioritize the well-being of their peers by accepting the possibility of failure. We should also commend public officials and the difficult personal decisions that lead to honesty, empathy, and decisive action. These choices will clearly differentiate between deceptive practices and genuine progress in the electoral process.

If political figures evade direct responses, legislation should be enacted to remove them from the decision-making process. The media must be held accountable for its coverage choices, debates, and commercial content, scrutinizing its own performance with the same rigor it applies to others.

The Impact of Time Delay on Content

A discussion has arisen regarding the time lag between show recording and its publication on Techcrunch, including post-production elements like music and promotional previews. Observing this delay, it’s apparent that it serves a valuable function: diminishing the immediacy of the conversation and introducing a beneficial layer of context derived from subsequent events.

While news is often described as a first draft of history, the constant demand for high ratings can transform insightful reporting into sensationalized clickbait.

Shades of Gray and Nuance

This filtering process allows for a more nuanced perspective, moving beyond stark contrasts and reflecting the collective viewpoint of the group. Consider the ongoing debate surrounding social media giants and the pressure for antitrust regulation. Some argue against interfering with the success of these companies in building audiences and market dominance, asserting that “if it isn’t broken, don’t fix it.”

Others contend that intervention is necessary to address the negative consequences of these emerging monopolies, which have flourished due to user engagement with commentary, satire, and personal updates. Alternatively, the conflict may center on the balance between individual rights and the collective good, as exemplified by the struggle to control COVID-19 through vaccination mandates.

A middle ground exists between these entrenched positions, potentially offering a more constructive path forward than simply being “right.”

Mandates, the New Normal, and the Creator Economy

The topic of mandates is a recurring theme. Current news focuses on New York City’s regulations regarding vaccinated access to indoor venues, but the broader issue concerns the federal government’s limited authority to implement a nationwide mandate and the resistance from governors in certain states, some of whom are actively preventing local governments from protecting their citizens. Where progress seemed impossible just two weeks ago, the New York initiative may encourage increased vaccination rates, supported by data showing a doubling of new vaccinations in affected states.

This positive data is increasingly incorporated into media coverage, diminishing the prominence of more divisive narratives. The overall effect is a more adaptable narrative that reinforces the idea that government can effectively address challenges, thereby reducing the distrust that fuels vaccine hesitancy.

The shift towards a “new normal” is a driving force behind the mandate discussion. The pandemic has accelerated digital transformation, leading to a growing recognition that a return to pre-pandemic life is unlikely. Instead, we are witnessing a foreshadowing of how we will live and work in the future.

We frequently discuss the creator economy on our show, acknowledging its potential while also recognizing the challenges faced by those attempting to establish themselves. Publications like The Information, which rely on subscriptions, offer a glimpse into the potential future of newsletter platforms like Substack and Twitter Revue.

Social audio platforms, inspired by Clubhouse, promise a similar escape from the limitations of traditional media. However, the path to success is often fraught with obstacles, including the difficulty of achieving meaningful differentiation and the overwhelming competition in the digital landscape.

The Future of Digital Platforms

The financial projections for both creators and social networks remain uncertain. Once the competition over features subsides, we may see a fragmented landscape of writers on platforms like Substack and Facebook, with limited opportunities for influencers and talent to gain widespread recognition. Corporate adoption of these tools could provide a growth opportunity for enterprise versions.

Whether this will be sufficient to sustain the tech industry remains to be seen. Perhaps in two weeks, a clearer picture will emerge.

from the Gillmor Gang Newsletter

__________________

The Gillmor Gang — Frank Radice, Michael Markman, Keith Teare, Denis Pombriant, Brent Leary and Steve Gillmor. Recorded live Friday, July 23, 2021.

Produced and directed by Tina Chase Gillmor @tinagillmor

@fradice, @mickeleh, @denispombriant, @kteare, @brentleary, @stevegillmor, @gillmorgang

Subscribe to the new Gillmor Gang Newsletter and join the backchannel here on Telegram.

The Gillmor Gang on Facebook … and here’s our sister show G3 on Facebook.