Gillmor Gang: Leave Quietly

The Pivotal Impact of Twitter's Actions

Interestingly, the most consequential choice wasn't the electoral outcome itself, but rather Twitter's decision to permanently suspend the former president's account. Following this action, a noticeable shift occurred. The incoming administration began actively addressing vaccine distribution strategies, and the subsequent impeachment trial concluded as anticipated.

While the impeachment proceedings lacked broad consensus, Twitter’s decision enjoyed bipartisan support. This demonstrates the platform’s influence on the political climate.

Revue Acquisition and the Future of Newsletters

Another significant development for Twitter was the acquisition of Revue, a direct competitor to Substack. We are now transitioning the production of the Gillmor Gang newsletter to this platform.

Revue offers features that allow for easy integration of content from sources like Twitter and Feedly. A key capability is the ability to rearrange these segments during the writing process.

The Evolution of Media Platforms

It is predicted that the newsletter format will ultimately encompass blogs, podcasts, and streaming media. This will result in a restructured media landscape accessible to creators of all sizes.

The Newsletter Model and Content Prioritization

This type of iterative development aligns perfectly with the newsletter approach. It fosters more frequent releases and emphasizes editorial quality over sheer volume.

As newsletters become increasingly prevalent, the value of time invested versus the amount of content produced becomes paramount. The focus shifts from simply attracting views to carefully curating what is selected for consumption and annotation through social recommendations.

Similar to Frank Radice’s Nuzzel newsletter, the emphasis moves away from a continuous stream of information and towards establishing authority and resonance.

Daily Commentary

A focused shift in coverage is being implemented within “The Radice Files,” concentrating exclusively on media analysis. Given the abundance of general news aggregators currently available, a deliberate choice has been made to move away from broader news reporting. It is hoped that readers will continue to follow this new direction.

Rather than continuous coverage of Donald Trump, the sole political story featured in the revised Radice File concerns Fox News’ decision to interrupt the broadcast of House manager video testimony. The network opted instead to present commentary questioning the value of covering the proceedings, considering the anticipated lack of votes for conviction. This practice isn't isolated to Fox News; similar occurrences are observed on centrist and left-leaning networks like CNN and MSNBC.

The focus isn’t on the networks’ bias, but rather on their underlying business models and the resulting impact on media programming. This is a key distinction.

The growing influence of streaming services is demonstrably impacting the technology landscape, as evidenced by the emergence of Clubhouse, the latest Silicon Valley “unicorn.” Marketed as an exclusive, real-time audio conversation platform, Clubhouse utilizes a viral onboarding mechanism through Twitter, deeply integrating with users’ contact lists.

High-profile events, such as a discussion featuring Elon Musk, are consistently oversubscribed from the moment they are announced. Attempts to join this week’s follow-up conversation with Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz proved unsuccessful, with the event reaching its 5,000-person capacity within 30 minutes.

However, a compelling element of Clubhouse is drawing attention as notifications arrive regarding user participation and room creation around various topics popular in Silicon Valley. The sense of immediacy and the potential for spontaneous, significant moments offer a unique experience.

This feeling evokes a sense of witnessing history unfold, rather than simply observing it. While potentially illusory, it mirrors the excitement experienced when playing a vinyl record and anticipating the artist’s performance. The enduring impact of Miles Davis’ “Kind of Blue” exemplifies this, with its ability to reshape one’s perception of time.

Reports indicate that Clubhouse sessions can range from one to five hours in duration. It’s been suggested that the RSS feed was ultimately undermined by its unread message indicator. Does duration matter? Possibly, according to prior research.

However, return on investment (ROI) is arguably more crucial, and this is where the Clubhouse phenomenon aligns with the current popularity of newsletters. Both formats rely on intuition, user choice, organic discovery, and valuable content.

Intuition

The question arises: does a given piece of information align with the patterns one is currently attempting to identify? Films such as “Citizen Kane” and “North By Northwest” are appreciated for their illusion of a universe predetermined by inherent biological factors. This is often referred to as fate or chance, yet frequently summarized with the phrase: "It is what it is."

However, a shift in perspective suggests: "It is what it is becoming." A sense of premonition accompanies events, a feeling of knowing they were likely to occur, given the prevailing global climate.

When engaging with newsletters, the strategy isn't exhaustive reading. Instead, focus is placed on discerning what to read, when to read it, and in what order. The reward for the reader is personalized content driven by analytics, while publishers gain validation of their content's impact through the interplay of curated sources and contextual writing.

Similarly, in platforms like Clubhouse, value lies in presence and timing – specifically, knowing when to disengage. This mirrors a desire to avoid the predictable conclusions of podcasts or the influence of underlying business models that shape future actions.

Consider the example of a Sunday tradition: perhaps tuning into “Meet the Press.” The possibility remains, however.

Options and Decisions

A multitude of choices present themselves: selecting a room, the individuals involved, the time commitment, and the potential for further investment. The decision also encompasses what is being neglected – employment, television news, family activities, or even rest.

Clubhouse offers a public listening experience, a broadcast notification that doesn't allow for anonymous observation. However, it facilitates a form of multitasking, enabling users to engage in activities like dishwashing, playing with pets, or silently watching television while participating.

Essentially, it represents a modern iteration of radio, unaffected by the pandemic. The core principle remains: one's inherent self accompanies them regardless of location.

The Newsletter Landscape

Newsletters involve considerations of audience, time spent reading, the need for research, subscriber acquisition, payment methods (monetary funds, credibility, or confidence), and the pursuit of influence or readership.

The underlying strategy involves exchanging existing media formats for the potential of future consolidation, fostering the growth of new publishers, content creators, and artists.

This shift represents a fundamental change in how information is disseminated and consumed.

The value exchange is complex, involving multiple factors beyond simple financial transactions.

Breadcrumb Trails in Digital Engagement

The decisions made in content strategy effectively establish a breadcrumb trail, replacing outdated approaches with innovative ones. Newsletters currently serve as a primary method for identifying emerging trends within memes, models, and markets, ultimately predicting what will gain widespread popularity. The analysis of open rates, click-through rates between email and web, and how notifications are prioritized provides valuable insights.

Successfully collecting these breadcrumbs necessitates creating new content based on the initial data gathered. Identifying a receptive audience is only the initial step in a more extensive process.

Initially, the focus is on recognizing indicators of positive engagement – the core elements of an experience that are rewarded through a blend of insight and action. This new media landscape functions as an informational investigation, encouraging in-depth reading, attentive listening, and active sharing.

The Power of Recurring Themes

Iconic phrases, such as “round up the usual suspects” or “we are not the droids you are looking for,” embody universal themes that help us navigate a complex and often challenging world. These media platforms offer potential alternative realities where we can not only endure but also uphold principles that align with our values.

The underlying concept is similar to a plotline in a film. Clubhouse, for example, operates on the assumption that there is a compelling narrative unfolding, with moments of empowerment derived from sharing and interpreting reactions as clues to understanding a shared subject.

While direct business secrets are unlikely to be revealed, valuable information can be gleaned from observing participant behavior. This includes their sense of humor, their timing for joining and participating, their success in being invited to speak, and their patterns of engagement and return.

The Cost of Insight

The exchange for this valuable data is the provision of your own breadcrumbs – the traces of your engagement and interaction. It’s understood intuitively that concrete business intelligence isn’t the primary goal.

Instead, the value lies in the subtle cues and patterns revealed through observation of user activity. Analyzing when individuals join, raise their hands, are selected to speak, and ultimately leave or return provides a rich dataset for understanding audience dynamics.

The Significance of Emerging Platforms

While the allure of Clubhouse has been noted, my direct engagement has been limited to only two instances. The initial entry occurred unintentionally, triggered by a simple link click to observe the room's participants. Subsequently, I joined a discussion centered around a Techmeme podcast, featuring both the podcast creator and Chris Messina, renowned for popularizing the hashtag. Despite this, I haven’t been drawn to the more prominent events hosted by A16Z.

Similar to Frank Radice’s shift in newsletter focus, my primary interest lies in the broader context of Andreessen Horowitz’s evolving media strategy. However, this doesn’t diminish the growing sense that a significant shift is underway within the media landscape.

The media industry as a whole is reassessing its position following recent political challenges. It’s important to note that this refers to media in general, rather than strictly defining it as “mainstream media” or “social media.” While distinctions can be debated, the differences between these categories may be less substantial than perceived, and ultimately, less indicative of the future value these new media formats will provide.

Increasingly, impactful writing disseminated through platforms like Twitter, RSS feeds (via Feedly), and aggregators such as Nuzzel and Medium, offers insightful perspectives on the critical issues we currently face. This includes established news organizations like the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, The Information, and specialized tech publications, as they integrate newsletter strategies with their existing resources.

A Convergence of Media Formats

We are witnessing a blending of different media types, with value and importance now being evaluated using novel metrics. In television, the NewFronts represent a combination of digital and traditional broadcasting. Within the music industry, focus has shifted to individual songs rather than complete albums.

Streaming services have fundamentally disrupted established networks, creating competition between Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Hulu, alongside legacy broadcasters like ABC, NBC, and CBS. Mergers and acquisitions have reshaped the industry, impacting companies like Fox, Time Warner, FX, and even Paramount Pictures.

Regarding radio, key players include Apple, Google, Amazon, and Spotify. However, platforms like Clubhouse, and previously Zoom, also hold considerable potential. While Twitter and Facebook have other priorities, Clubhouse is likely to integrate with emerging platforms such as Apple Car and Apple Glasses, particularly as we transition towards a future of autonomous work and remote accessibility.

The core value proposition driving this digital shift centers around value, efficient time management, and effective notification systems.

Originally published in the Gillmor Gang Newsletter

__________________

The Gillmor Gang consists of Frank Radice, Michael Markman, Keith Teare, Denis Pombriant, Brent Leary, and Steve Gillmor. This episode was recorded live on Friday, February 19, 2021.

Production and direction were handled by Tina Chase Gillmor @tinagillmor.

Connect with the team: @fradice, @mickeleh, @denispombriant, @kteare, @brentleary, @stevegillmor, @gillmorgang

Stay informed by subscribing to the Gillmor Gang Newsletter and participate in discussions on Telegram.

Find the Gillmor Gang on Facebook, and explore our companion show, G3, also on Facebook.