Amsterdam's Vacation Rental Ban Overturned by Court Ruling

A prohibition enacted by Amsterdam’s municipal government concerning short-term property rentals in three of the city’s central areas has been invalidated following a judicial review, which determined the ban lacked a legal foundation.

Response to Tourism Concerns

The city’s initial action was a direct response to escalating anxieties regarding the effects of platforms such as Airbnb on the living standards of local inhabitants.

Permit Applications to Resume

According to an update on the city’s official website, property owners will once again be able to submit applications for permits allowing holiday rentals within the previously restricted neighborhoods, starting tomorrow.

City officials have stated they are currently analyzing the court’s decision and will provide further details on the website as they become available.

Original Ban Details

Last summer, Amsterdam authorities implemented a ban on vacation rentals within the Burgwallen-Oude Zijde, Burgwallen-Nieuwe Zijde, and Grachtengordel-Zuid districts. This decision followed a public consultation that revealed substantial resident support for the measure.

The growth in tourist accommodations was identified as a key factor negatively impacting the quality of life for those residing in these areas.

Existing Permit System

Previously, the city had established a permit system to regulate vacation rentals in other districts. This system currently limits rentals to a maximum of 30 nights annually and restricts occupancy to four individuals per rental unit.

A crucial stipulation of the permit mandates that “guests must not create any disturbances.”

This existing permit system will now also be applicable within the three central districts following the court’s ruling.

Legal Challenge by Homeowners

The ban in the central districts was legally challenged by Amsterdam Gastvrij, an organization representing homeowners who utilize platforms like Airbnb to rent out their properties. Their argument centered on the assertion that the Housing Act 2014 did not authorize a complete prohibition on holiday rentals.

Court's Judgement

The Court of Amsterdam concurred with this assessment, stating in its official judgement that “a permit system cannot encompass a total prohibition.”

The court further elaborated that “individuals who fulfill the permit’s requirements are, in principle, entitled to a permit. A comprehensive ban represents a significant infringement upon property rights and the freedom of service provision, and would only be justifiable under exceptional circumstances.”

Airbnb's Response

An Airbnb spokesperson confirmed the company did not directly participate in the legal challenge but acknowledged the significance of the court’s decision.

Potential for Amended Regulations

Despite the ruling, the court has indicated that the city retains the ability to revise its legislation to incorporate additional conditions into the permit system, potentially including considerations related to “quality of life.”

The court also suggested the feasibility of implementing a quota system based on the number of nights rented, or enforcing residential use through zoning regulations. These options provide alternative policy tools for Amsterdam’s officials to manage short-term rental activity.

Broader European Context

This case highlights the difficulties European cities encounter when attempting to regulate the impact of rental platforms on housing availability, affordability, and the overall quality of life for residents facing over-tourism.

Calls for EU Regulation

In recent years, numerous major European tourist destinations have voiced frustration with vacation rental platforms, even submitting an open letter to the European Commission in 2019. This letter requested “strong legal obligations for platforms to cooperate with registration schemes and provide rental data for each property advertised.”

The cities emphasized the need to protect public interests and mitigate negative consequences such as increased disturbances, security concerns, and the “touristification” of neighborhoods.

They urged EU policymakers to reconsider existing regulations to allow for localized governance.

Commission's Response and DSA

The Commission has since initiated a limited data-sharing agreement with leading vacation rental platforms, aiming to foster “balanced” development of peer-to-peer rentals.

The Dutch government has also advocated for greater data access to vacation rental platforms, proposing its inclusion in the planned update to pan-EU digital services rules, known as the Digital Services Act (DSA).

The DSA, currently undergoing the EU’s legislative process, focuses on standardizing procedures for addressing illegal goods and services, potentially impacting vacation platforms regarding data-sharing related to unlawful rentals (those operating without the necessary permits).

Event Announcement

• Event: Early Stage – a “how-to” event for startup entrepreneurs and investors.
• Content: Fundraising, recruiting, sales, product-market fit, PR, marketing, and brand building.
• Discount: Use code “TCARTICLE” for 20% off tickets.