Android Desktop PCs and Laptops: Are They Worth Buying?
The Rise of Android Desktop PCs and Laptops
Computer manufacturers are increasingly developing all-in-one Android desktop computers. Alongside these, Android laptops and 2-in-1 convertible devices – capable of switching between a traditional laptop format and a tablet – are also becoming available.
However, a key question arises: is purchasing such a device a worthwhile investment?
Android's Strengths and Limitations
In essence, Android currently functions more effectively within the tablet ecosystem. Conversely, the full capabilities of the Windows operating system are far better realized on conventional desktop PCs and laptops.
These Android-powered devices often resemble significantly larger tablets in functionality, rather than mirroring the performance of typical personal computers.
Understanding the Device Category
It’s important to recognize that these Android desktops and laptops occupy a unique space in the market. They aren’t necessarily direct replacements for traditional PCs.
Consider their capabilities carefully before making a purchase. They excel at certain tasks, but may fall short when compared to the versatility of Windows-based systems.
Key Considerations Before Buying
- Intended Use: What tasks will you primarily perform?
- Software Compatibility: Will your required applications run on Android?
- Performance Expectations: Do you need the power of a full desktop OS?
Evaluating these factors will help determine if an Android desktop or laptop aligns with your specific needs and expectations.
The Emergence of Android PCs
Android-based desktop PCs share similarities with all-in-one Windows 8 computers. These systems fundamentally integrate computer components within a large touchscreen monitor, specifically intended for stationary desktop environments.
Alternatively, these devices can be viewed as substantially sized Android tablets engineered for fixed-location operation. A prime example is the Acer TA272 HUL, an all-in-one PC priced at $1100, featuring a 27-inch display and the Android operating system.
Android Laptops and Convertibles
Android laptops and 2-in-1 convertible devices echo the design of their Windows 8 counterparts. They are characterized by touchscreen displays and often include detachable keyboards.
This design allows for versatile usage, enabling the keyboard to be removed for tablet-style operation without obstruction.
Considering the landscape of Windows 8.1 devices, these Android PCs present a viable option. If the primary use case revolves around the touch-centric interface and applications, Android emerges as a strong contender.
Android currently boasts a significantly larger library of touch-optimized applications compared to Windows 8.
App Ecosystem Comparison
Furthermore, Android provides access to applications and games originally developed for smartphones, expanding the available touch app universe beyond the limitations of the Windows Store.
It's important to note that Windows Phone 8 applications are not compatible with Windows 8. While Windows 8’s Snap feature facilitates multitasking with multiple apps simultaneously, potentially enhancing usability on larger screens, the app selection remains a key differentiator.
Here's a breakdown of key considerations:
- Android PCs offer a touch-first experience.
- They provide access to a wider range of touch apps.
- Windows 8 offers better multitasking capabilities.
- App availability remains a crucial factor.
Android's Limitations Compared to the Windows Desktop EnvironmentConversely, Android does not present a viable alternative to the Windows desktop when robust desktop applications are required. Android can achieve comparable functionality to Windows 8 when limited to a touch-based interface; however, this is not the typical usage scenario for most users.
A significant proportion of Windows 8 users continue to rely on the conventional Windows desktop and its associated applications.
Further Reading: 4 Methods for Running Android on Your PC to Create a "Dual OS" Configuration
If a powerful PC experience utilizing a mouse and keyboard is desired, bypassing Android PCs is advisable. Android-based desktops and laptops essentially function as enlarged tablets, which may satisfy certain user needs, but fall short of being a comprehensive replacement for a Windows desktop or laptop PC.
The capabilities of the Windows desktop are such that Android applications can even be executed within a Windows environment. While potentially less streamlined, this demonstrates the inherent strength of a fully-featured desktop operating system.
Consider the following points:
- Application Compatibility: Windows boasts a far wider range of compatible software.
- Processing Power: Windows systems generally offer greater processing capabilities.
- Peripheral Support: Windows provides broader support for various peripherals and hardware.
Ultimately, while Android has its strengths, it doesn't currently match the versatility and power of the Windows desktop for users who require traditional desktop functionality.
Android's Constraints on Larger Screens
The Android operating system functions effectively on smartphones and compact tablets, such as the Nexus 7. However, its architecture wasn't originally conceived for desktop personal computers featuring larger, 27-inch displays.
A key difference lies in window management. Android is fundamentally designed to display only a single application at any given time.
Multitasking is restricted, as the platform doesn't natively support multiple windows appearing simultaneously on the screen. While adequate for smaller form factors like phones, this presents a significant drawback when utilized on a desktop PC.
Although floating apps offer a workaround for viewing multiple applications concurrently, their functionality is limited to a select range of specifically developed programs.
Input Device Considerations
Android provides acceptable keyboard compatibility, but its mouse integration isn't fully optimized. A fundamental feature absent from Android is the "right-click" functionality.
The mouse cursor is displayed, and a left-click action is interpreted as a touch event. Consequently, users are unable to access context menus through a right-click action.
This limitation impacts user workflows and the overall desktop experience.
Consider these points when evaluating Android-based desktop solutions.
Exploring the Potential of Android-Based Computing
The concept of Android convertibles presents a viable option for users. These devices combine the functionality of an Android tablet with the convenience of a dockable keyboard. This configuration facilitates quicker email composition, document creation, and other typing-intensive tasks while mobile.
Similar to how iPads are utilized as lightweight laptop alternatives, an Android laptop could fulfill a comparable role. This is particularly appealing to those who favor the Android operating system over iOS, or who are seeking a more cost-effective solution.
Challenges with Android Desktop PCs
An Android desktop PC, however, poses more significant questions regarding its practicality. Due to its inherent lack of portability, its use case is largely limited to a stationary environment.
One potential application lies in the realm of touch-based kiosk systems. Such systems could leverage Android’s interface to offer users access to games, web browsing, and a broader range of applications than traditionally found in Windows 8.
Despite these possibilities, an Android desktop doesn’t readily replace traditional operating systems like Windows, Mac OS X, desktop Linux, or even Chrome OS. These alternatives are better suited for demanding desktop workloads requiring multi-window functionality.
- Portability: Convertibles offer mobility, while desktops do not.
- Application Support: Desktop OSes generally provide a wider range of professional software.
- Use Cases: Convertibles excel at on-the-go productivity; desktops may suit kiosk applications.
Ultimately, the suitability of an Android-based computer depends heavily on the intended application and the user’s specific needs.
The Questionable Appeal of Android Desktops
Related: Adapting to a Chromebook Lifestyle: Is a Chrome Browser Enough?
Android-based convertibles, essentially tablets paired with keyboard attachments, present a logical proposition. However, the concept of Android desktops currently lacks substantial merit. Google itself doesn't consider Android suitable for traditional desktop or laptop environments, actively promoting Chrome OS for these platforms.
Given Google’s lack of investment in Android as a desktop solution, the rationale for a consumer purchase is diminished. Resources and improvements will continue to be directed towards Chrome OS for desktop and laptop devices, rather than Android.
Why Consider Alternatives?
The question remains: is acquiring an Android desktop PC a wise investment? Most likely, it is not.
An Android laptop or convertible might be considered, but only if your primary need is an Android tablet enhanced with a keyboard. These should be viewed as tablets with expanded functionality, rather than replacements for conventional laptops.
Image sources: Peter Kaminski (Flickr), Acer, Cheon Fong Liew (Flickr), Sergey Galyonkin (Flickr), Matthew Pearce (Flickr), claudia.rahanmetan (Flickr)