Windows 8.1 Upgrade: Why Users Haven't Made the Switch

Windows 8.1 Adoption: A Paradoxical Situation

Windows 8.1 was released as a complimentary update for those already utilizing Windows 8. It represented a significant refinement of the initial Windows 8 experience, incorporating crucial enhancements designed to benefit both traditional desktop computer users and those employing tablet devices.

Despite these improvements, a curious trend has emerged: the number of users operating Windows 8 continues to exceed those who have transitioned to Windows 8.1.

Analyzing the Lower-Than-Expected Uptake

This disparity presents a notable challenge for Microsoft. Windows 8.1 marked the first instance of the company offering a substantial version upgrade of its operating system at no cost to its existing user base.

However, the adoption rate among Windows 8 users has been surprisingly low, suggesting a potential misstep in user engagement or perceived value.

Key Considerations

Free Upgrade: The offer of a free upgrade was intended to incentivize adoption.
Improvements: Windows 8.1 addressed many criticisms leveled against Windows 8.
User Inertia: A possible factor is simply user reluctance to change operating systems.

The reasons behind this phenomenon warrant further investigation to understand the factors influencing user behavior and the effectiveness of Microsoft’s upgrade strategy.

Windows 8.1 Adoption Rates

Windows 8.1 was initially made available on October 17, 2013, marking over four months since its launch.

Microsoft is preparing to distribute another substantial update, officially titled Windows 8.1 Update 1, in the coming month.

Current Usage Figures

Despite the availability of the free update, a greater number of users continue to operate with Windows 8 compared to Windows 8.1.

Data from NetMarketShare indicates a 6.83% usage share for Windows 8, while Windows 8.1 currently holds a 4.3% share.

Unexpected Trends

A complete disappearance of Windows 8 from the market isn't anticipated in the short term.

However, it is surprising to observe Windows 8 exceeding Windows 8.1 in usage by such a considerable difference.

This is particularly noteworthy considering the significant issues present in the original Windows 8 release and the extensive improvements implemented in Windows 8.1 to enhance user experience.

why-have-most-windows-8-users-not-upgraded-to-windows-8.1-1.jpg

The Windows 8.1 Update: Found in the Windows Store, Not Windows Update

Related: A Visual Guide to the New Features in Windows 8.1 Update 1

Historically, Microsoft delivered Windows updates through the Windows Update service. Major updates, often termed Service Packs, were integrated into Windows Update alongside routine patches. This provided a centralized location for users to receive all Microsoft updates, with automatic installation as a standard feature.

Windows 8 continues to utilize this established method, offering updates via Windows Update and enabling automated installation. However, the Windows 8.1 update diverges from this convention.

The Windows 8.1 update is not accessible through Windows Update. Instead, it is distributed via the Windows Store – the application found within the modern, full-screen interface previously known as Metro.

Many Windows 8 users, particularly those utilizing the operating system on non-touch devices, rarely interact with this application.

Understanding the Windows Store's Role

The Windows Store primarily features touch-optimized applications designed for the interface formerly called Metro, now referred to as "Store apps."

While the Store does provide links to some traditional desktop applications, these links simply redirect users to download the application installer for standard installation. Consequently, there's no practical advantage to using the Store for desktop software.

Notably, even Windows 8.1 Update 1 will become available through Windows Update for those already running Windows 8.1. The rationale behind this dual distribution method remains unclear, especially considering the substantial nature of Windows 8.1 Update 1, which includes significant interface modifications, mirroring the changes introduced with Windows 8.1 itself.

why-have-most-windows-8-users-not-upgraded-to-windows-8.1-2.jpg

Microsoft Account Necessity

Important Notice: A Microsoft representative has clarified that, despite the update’s presence in the Store, a Microsoft account isn't actually needed for download. Our initial assessment was incorrect; however, the Windows 8.1 preview necessitated a Microsoft account for Store downloads, and generally, no Store functionality operates without one.

Further Reading: A Comprehensive List of Windows 10 Features Requiring a Microsoft Account

Windows 8 provides the flexibility to sign in using either a Microsoft account or a local user profile. Microsoft actively encourages the use of Microsoft accounts, which explains why the local account option is less prominent.

Desktop users can typically function effectively with local user profiles. However, Microsoft mandates a Microsoft account login to download Windows 8.1 via the Store. An alternative workaround involves creating a new user account, associating it with a Microsoft account, installing Windows 8.1, and then removing the account.

Most users are unlikely to pursue this method. Microsoft anticipates that many Windows 8 users will choose to log in with a Microsoft account to obtain the update and subsequently remain logged in, transitioning from a local account to a Microsoft account.

why-have-most-windows-8-users-not-upgraded-to-windows-8.1-3.jpg

Why the Hesitation to Adopt New Windows Versions in Business?

A common observation is that companies frequently delay adopting the newest releases of Windows. They tend to favor stability and familiarity over immediate upgrades to the latest software iterations.

Consider the extended period many organizations continued to rely on Windows XP, only recently initiating updates – often directly to Windows 7. This illustrates a preference for proven systems.

Consequently, is a similar pattern unfolding with Windows 8, where businesses are postponing upgrades to Windows 8.1? It seems improbable.

For risk-averse organizations, Windows 8.1 represents a significant enhancement over Windows 8. It provides a refined user experience for those utilizing traditional keyboards and mice, alongside the reinstatement of the Start button.

Even in environments employing tablets, Windows 8.1 delivers substantial improvements. These include a more robust Snap functionality and the introduction of new applications.

It’s improbable that widespread standardization on Windows 8 is driving this reluctance to upgrade to 8.1. However, some businesses may be hesitant.

This hesitation likely stems from a perception of Windows 8.1 as a completely new operating system requiring thorough evaluation, rather than recognizing it as the enhanced service pack for Windows 8 that it truly is.

Mac OS X vs. Windows Upgrade Rates

A notable trend exists where Mac users generally adopt new iterations of Mac OS X at a faster rate compared to PC users updating to newer Windows versions.

This difference is partially attributable to cost; the release of OS X 10.8 Mavericks was offered without charge, and all subsequent versions have followed this pricing model.

However, it's important to note that Windows 8.1 was also made available as a free upgrade for existing Windows 8 users.

Mac OS X Version Usage

Data from NetMarketShare reveals the distribution of Mac OS X versions currently in use.

Specifically, Mac OS X 10.8 holds a 2.09% share, while Mac OS X 10.7 and 10.6 each account for 2.13% and 2.17% of usage, respectively.

Interestingly, a significant proportion of Mac users continue to operate older Mac OS X versions, even with the availability of the latest free upgrade.

This suggests that slower adoption rates aren't exclusive to the Microsoft ecosystem.

OS X 10.8 Mavericks: 2.09% usage
OS X 10.7: 2.13% usage
OS X 10.6: 2.17% usage

The prevalence of older versions among Mac users raises questions about the factors influencing upgrade decisions across different operating systems.

Operating System Versions Compared to Updates and Service Packs

A significant factor contributing to the continued use of Windows 8 by many individuals may be Microsoft’s decision to classify Windows 8.1 as a distinct operating system version, rather than a service pack or conventional update.

The arrival of Windows 8.1 Update 1 through Windows Update will likely result in a widespread upgrade among existing Windows 8.1 users. Consequently, a direct comparison of market share between Windows 8.1 and Windows 8.1 Update 1 systems is deemed unnecessary.

Related: The End of Support for Windows XP on April 8th, 2014: Understanding the Warnings

Had Windows 8.1 been distributed via Windows Update, a much larger proportion of Windows 8 users would likely have transitioned to it by this point, given their familiarity with the Windows Update process.

Considering that almost 30% of internet users still rely on Windows XP, Microsoft’s priority should be to avoid creating another obsolete Windows version that users will continue to employ. Making Windows 8.1 accessible through Windows Update would prevent Microsoft from perpetually supporting older iterations of Windows, such as the initial release of Windows 8.

Instead of a standard update, Microsoft opted for a more prominent release of a new Windows version. This approach, by increasing the complexity of upgrading, has inadvertently left a substantial number of users operating on Windows 8 instead of the newer Windows 8.1. This situation is ultimately detrimental to all parties involved.

Image Credit: Pete on Flickr