Windows 8: How Microsoft Is Changing the Desktop Experience
The Evolution of the Windows Desktop
While the familiar desktop environment persists within Windows 8, it represents arguably the most refined iteration to date, though notably lacking a traditional Start menu.
However, Microsoft’s introduction of the Windows 8 desktop signals a strategic shift, effectively positioning the traditional desktop for eventual obsolescence.
A Clear Direction: Touch and Metro
The indications are clear: touch interaction and the Metro interface are being prioritized as the future of the Windows experience.
The conventional desktop is increasingly viewed as a legacy component, destined for decline.
The Consumer Preview: A Defining Vision
Although Windows 8 remains under development, the release of the Consumer Preview provides a comprehensive glimpse into Microsoft’s ultimate product design.
This preview is described by Microsoft as embodying “the complete vision” for Windows 8.
Further refinements and bug fixes are anticipated, but the core functionality and user experience presented in the Consumer Preview are representative of the final product.
Essentially, the Windows 8 we see now is the Windows 8 we are ultimately going to receive.
The Inevitability of Metro in Windows 8
The Metro interface is a required component of Windows 8. Regardless of personal preference, all users will encounter it upon logging in. Accessing the traditional desktop necessitates clicking the "Desktop" tile within the Metro environment.
Once on the desktop, Metro functions as the new Start menu. Shutting down the computer also requires utilizing the charms bar, a feature integrated within Metro. While third-party Start menu alternatives are available, Microsoft itself does not provide one.
Metro's Deep Integration
Previously, in the Windows 8 Developer Preview, a registry modification allowed for complete Metro disabling and restoration of the classic Start menu. However, Metro is now fundamentally integrated into the core Explorer.exe process.
Complete removal now potentially requires employing a Windows Explorer shell replacement. This signifies a substantial shift in the operating system's architecture.
Microsoft maintains that Windows 8 is designed for usability without requiring desktop interaction, especially for tablet users. For PC users who prefer to avoid Metro, this is not an option. The operating system does not offer a built-in toggle to disable it.
Furthermore, Microsoft has declined to implement a mechanism for businesses to disable Metro through group policy settings. This lack of administrative control has been a point of contention for some organizations.
The Shift from “Metro” to “Modern”
The recently released interface was initially known as “Metro.” However, Microsoft has officially rebranded “Metro” as “Modern.” This means “Metro” is now formally referred to as “the Modern interface.”
Consequently, Internet Explorer operating within this new environment is designated as “Modern Internet Explorer.” Generally, applications designed for this interface are now termed “Modern apps.”
The Declining Role of the Traditional Desktop
Within the evolving Windows environment, the conventional desktop and its associated applications are increasingly perceived as outdated. This perception is further reinforced by the user experience.
The Start screen exhibits a visual disconnect when populated with desktop applications rather than those built for the Modern interface. Microsoft possesses the capability to integrate desktop apps with live tiles, enabling a more cohesive aesthetic.
However, the company appears to be intentionally positioning traditional desktop applications as legacy components. A deliberate design choice seems to be fostering a sense of obsolescence for these older programs.
The Central Role of Touch in Windows 8
The Windows 8 Metro interface was initially conceived and developed prioritizing touch-based interaction. While Microsoft has made efforts to enhance compatibility with traditional input methods like keyboards and mice in the Consumer Preview, these additions appear to be secondary considerations.
Despite improvements, it’s evident that keyboard and mouse support was integrated after the core design was established.
Navigating the Lock Screen
Consider the lock screen experience within the Windows 8 Desktop environment, as illustrated below:
A key question arises: how does a user transition from the lock screen to the login screen? Interestingly, there is no conventional clickable button for this purpose.
Instead, users are required to utilize a drag-and-drop gesture to dismiss the lock screen. This action feels intuitive on a touchscreen device, but can seem awkward and unconventional when using a mouse.
Keyboard input also functions – any key press will bypass the lock screen – however, this functionality isn’t immediately apparent to users.
A Disconnect for Non-Touch Users
Even without a touchscreen laptop, the Metro interface evokes a desire for tactile interaction. The visual design is inherently appealing and suggests a touch-friendly experience.
However, the interface doesn’t consistently translate well to mouse-driven navigation, creating a sense that it wasn’t primarily designed for this input method.
The Desktop's Role as a Metro Application
Within the updated task switcher, each active Metro application is represented by its own thumbnail. However, the traditional desktop is displayed as a single tile within this same switcher.
Microsoft positions the desktop as the environment for running older, legacy software. This includes programs like the Flash browser plugin or established business applications. The lack of Metro-style theming on the desktop reinforces its status as a legacy environment.
Essentially, the desktop could be considered “Windows 7 Mode,” given its distinct appearance and function.
ARM Architecture and Desktop Application Restrictions
Users acquiring a Windows 8 tablet based on the ARM processor may anticipate access to the conventional desktop environment. While the desktop interface remains present, its functionality is deliberately limited.
Access to the desktop is restricted to Microsoft applications, including Microsoft Office and Windows Explorer, alongside other software developed by Microsoft.
Limitations on Third-Party Software
A key restriction is the inability to install applications not originating from Microsoft onto the ARM-based desktop environment.
This limitation extends beyond mere compatibility issues; Microsoft actively prevents the execution of third-party applications within the ARM desktop interface.
Consequently, individuals desiring to utilize software from developers other than Microsoft are directed to employ the Metro interface.
The Metro interface serves as the exclusive platform for running non-Microsoft applications on these ARM systems.
The Evolution of Software Acquisition with the Windows App Store
A significant development within Windows 8 is the debut of the Windows App Store. Traditionally, software installation on Windows has presented challenges. Users were required to obtain installers from various websites for each application and navigate through individual installation processes.
Following installation, each program typically managed its own update mechanism. This created a fragmented and time-consuming experience.
The Windows App Store aims to streamline this process. It centralizes updates, potentially saving users considerable time and effort.
However, this benefit is currently limited. The Windows App Store primarily caters to Metro apps. While it may feature links to conventional desktop applications, these will still necessitate manual downloads and installations.
Consequently, desktop programs on Windows 8 will continue to rely on their individual update utilities.
Microsoft acknowledges the existing difficulties surrounding software installation and updates on Windows. Their approach, however, focuses on resolving these issues within the Metro environment, rather than addressing them across the entire desktop platform.
This strategy appears to be geared towards encouraging a transition away from the traditional desktop experience.
The app store facilitates automatic installation and updates for Metro applications, ensuring synchronization across multiple devices. Furthermore, it establishes a controlled ecosystem, restricting Metro app acquisition to the store itself – effectively eliminating the installation of unofficial, third-party software.
Here's a summary of the key changes:
- Centralized app updates
- Streamlined installation process for Metro apps
- Controlled app distribution through the store
- Continued manual updates for desktop applications
What are your impressions of the redesigned Windows 8 desktop? Do you agree with this assessment? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Related Posts
Touchscreen on Windows PC: Do You Need It?
Find Lost Windows or Office Product Keys - Easy Guide
Windows 10 Resetting Settings: Why It Happens & How to Fix
Monitor FPS in UWP Games on Windows 10 - A Simple Guide
Remove 'Get Windows 10' Icon & Stop Upgrade Notifications
